Comments: 6
That sounds like a frustrating read! I'm all for language experiments and all, as long as author's realize they might not be widely read (and not due to lack of intelligence in their readers!).
Well, Lispector has incredible traction with the critical community and Colm Tóibín is literally falling over himself with admiration in the preface, so obviously there are *some* people out there (and even fairly many, considering Lispector's stature in Brazilian literature) who love and admire this sort of thing. And who knows, maybe 30 years ago I'd have found it an interesting experiment. But I'm definitely in a place now where I can no longer appreciate it. Give me Barbara Pym any day of the week instead ...
It's the kind of thing I'm *supposed* to like, as a former literature professor, but to be honest it's a style that's always bored me to tears. And it's not because of a lack of plot or characters etc. It's simply because for word experimentation, I prefer to turn to poetry, which does it better because it's not also (usually) pretending to have a plot.
That's true actually -- poetry lends itself to linguistic deconstruction fairly easily; to a certain extent it even calls for it in order to break with convention. But prose ... ugh. Give me intelligible sentences (and dialogue) and I'll happily trot along; if you've sufficiently hooked me otherwise, even without much of a plot (or without much of a focus on characters, for that matter). Make your sentences sound like you've randomly assembled them from a LEGO set -- or, as Lispector does, overtly pretend this is what you've done, only to then deconstruct that pretence in turn, too -- and we part company fast. And I'm glad to hear not everybody who "is supposed to" like this sort of thing actually does! :)
Linda Hilton 6 years ago
I read a collection of Lispector's short stories (maybe?) in 1998 for a course in 20th Century Non-US/CAN/UK/AUS Women Authors, most in translation. Most of the readings had at least something to recommend them, even if it was just the grim reality of a Chinese prison for critics of the government. Lispector's offered nothing, as far as I was concerned. I remember absolutely nothing about them.
I'm not surprised.