This just made me smile. I was born in 1967 and have also been a Tolkein fan for about 30 years, ever since I had the role of the elf who says "Most astonishingly wonderful!" in a school district-wide play during the '74/'75 school year. Tolkein opened up new/old worlds for so many of us.
Those are the covers of the edition of LOTR I got from the library. The Hobbit had the cover with the emu and pomegranate.