Thanks for the reminder re Choice Awards ... I totally agree with you on the choices that are being put forward. I don't usually read a lot of new releases, but this year I added a few that weren't listed and voted for them instead. It won't make a difference as the books won't even show, but one I wanted to nominate was Le Guins last book "No Time to Spare" in the memoir category.
After I nominated it, I went to the book page and asked why it wans't nominated. Hopefully this will get some of its other readers to nominate it as well!
I share your cynicism. There's usually a lot of lightweight Romance/borderline erotica in these GR awards, regardless of genre. I stopped even looking years ago.
The Goodreads Awards are a prime example of why I'm automatically suspicious of virtually every book that is hyped as an awards-winner ... or a bestseller. They're not the reason for my suspicion, which vastly predates their existence, but they embody everything I detest.