Comments: 10
BrokenTune 9 years ago
Great rant. Thanks for the insights. I was wondering about the book - it being praised so much - but the things you mention would ensure I'd regret reading it.
The English Student 9 years ago
Thanks - I really needed to sound off about it! Yeah, I wouldn't recommend it. At all.
From your description, I can envision Cline saying "some of my best friends are X, so I'm not [insert insult here]."
The English Student 9 years ago
Yes! That's actually how the whole book felt to me - one long "my best friend is..."
Hol 9 years ago
Ha! Great review.
The English Student 9 years ago
Thanks!
bookaneer 9 years ago
Nice rant. This all bugged me too, plus the incredibly stereotyped Japanese characters, plus the fact that every other female character is described as a slut, etc, etc.
And the part where Aech says that the internet is the best thing that could happen to minorities because apparently the author believes conforming and erasure are the same as diversity? Ye gods.
The English Student 9 years ago
Oh, yes, the Japanese characters and the three words of Japanese that got deployed at every opportunity so the author could show off his "knowledge" (despite the fact that it's mentioned at least twice that both are FLUENT IN ENGLISH).

And, I agree, the whole of Aech's storyline is really, really problematic and tokenistic and rage-inducing: "Look, my story full of nerdy white kids is actually secretly diverse! One of them was only pretending to be white!"

I don't actually remember the slut-shaming, but I may have been too blinded by rage at that point...
The English Student 9 years ago
I actually can't remember ever being so angry about a book. And no-one I see on a day-to-day basis is particularly bookish, so I really needed to vent!