logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Gaslight Grimoire: Fantastic Tales of Sherlock Holmes - Community Reviews back

by Charles Prepolec, J.R. Campbell, Kim Newman, Barbara Roden, M.J. Elliott, Peter Calamai, Phil Cornell, David Stuart Davies, Rick Kennett, Chico Kidd, Barbara Hambly, Christopher Sequeira, Bob Madison, Martin Powell, Chris Roberson
sort by language
Intensely Focused
Intensely Focused rated it 7 years ago
I thought this anthology was uneven. There were a few stories that really stood out but most didn't make a lasting impression. I liked The Lost Boy by Barbara Hambly/ It was interesting reading a story from Mary's point of view. But it was really the idea of a young Sherlock in Neverland that pique...
The Charcoal Burner
The Charcoal Burner rated it 10 years ago
Unlike the reviewer at SF Site, I felt that the best of the bunch was the story that didn't include Holmes -- the incomparable Kim Newman's 'The Red Planet League'. The rest were readable, at times even quite good -- with the possible exception of editor J.R. Campbell's awkward pulp offering 'The E...
Need help?