logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Lirael: Daughter of the Clayr (The Old Kingdom Trilogy, #2) - Community Reviews back

by Garth Nix
sort by language
A World of Make Believe
A World of Make Believe rated it 13 years ago
I can easily say that I am completely in love with this series. They are literally everything I have been looking for in a YA series. My only regret is that I never read these when I was younger (I was constantly picking them up at the library, but I never actually read them). Lirael is the sequel t...
By Singing Light
By Singing Light rated it 13 years ago
I loved Sabriel, so I was excited for the sequel. I did like it, though it does one of those abrupt time jumps that I often find disconcerting. Lirael is a new character and I found her journey a little less interesting and convincing than Sabriel’s. In general, the world-building that I had liked i...
Something clever I'll change later
Something clever I'll change later rated it 13 years ago
This review can also be read on my blog, Stumptown Books.Everything that was awesome about the first installation of the series, Sabriel, got completely muddled and lost in this sequel. I loved the first book, and had high hopes with following it up. Those hopes have been dashed. Mercilessly.We b...
Bibliobimbo
Bibliobimbo rated it 13 years ago
Sweet Lord, I finally finished it! I started this book a couple of months ago, and I would get into it for awhile and then put it down without any desire to pick it up again. This should have been a book that I loved--I really enjoyed Sabriel, the first book in the series, and this one is about a li...
Basically Books
Basically Books rated it 14 years ago
http://basicallybooks1994.blogspot.com/
Page Turning Paula
Page Turning Paula rated it 14 years ago
Bit of a slower start than Sabriel, but SO GOOD. I didn't think it could get better. but it definitely did. My love of Mogget grew and I found a new love in The Deplorable Dog. So glad I have the third book so I don't have to wait out the cliffhanger!
Dichotomygirl
Dichotomygirl rated it 14 years ago
I thought this was better than Sabriel, the first book in the series.
random library adventures
random library adventures rated it 14 years ago
I love Nix's female characters. More shy brunettes please.
Miss Clark
Miss Clark rated it 15 years ago
Decent start, but I got bored fairly quickly. Again, expected much more since so many people I know rated it so highly. Oh well.Slow. Pacing threw me. Plot was all over. And most things were seen coming from behind the backs of sneaky DEAD minions from twenty pages away.
The City Of Invention
The City Of Invention rated it 15 years ago
Like its predecessor, Sabriel, Lirael is a remarkable feat of imaginative storytelling. Utterly gripping, it is, in Philip Pullman's words, 'fantasy that reads like realism'.It's a continuation of the story that began with Sabriel, though the point of view has moved to that of a teenage girl growing...
Need help?