logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Promise in a Kiss - Community Reviews back

by Piper Vaughn
sort by language
Reckless Indulgence on BL
Reckless Indulgence on BL rated it 6 years ago
This review can be found in its entirety on my blog:Reckless Indulgence | of the Written WordIt was cute. A "Disney-fairytale-ending" sort of cute. Short and to the point. Predictable, but that's not all that bad a thing, in this case. I liked it, but that's about it. Don't know if I'd recommend it ...
jilrene reads
jilrene reads rated it 7 years ago
Sweet, sweet short story.
elspeth's ephemeral musings
elspeth's ephemeral musings rated it 8 years ago
This story was just a tease, nothing really was accomplished.
Mandy, I read obsessively
Mandy, I read obsessively rated it 9 years ago
Really sweet and cute story about childhood friends finding each other after 15years.But it ended far to soon!
Stumbling Over Chaos
Stumbling Over Chaos rated it 9 years ago
2.5 stars. Ok short m/m romance about two guys who made a promise to each other when they were kids, then lost touch. While this was sweet, it felt more like a tease than an actual story.
blub
blub rated it 9 years ago
The idea of a marriage proposal at childhood has been done in lots of manga so the idea of it actually happening isn't unbelievable. It's a bit farfetched to believe that the 2 MC's came to the same though of meeting up with each other at the same time but if you're a big believer of fate the story ...
You Know Me As Lad
You Know Me As Lad rated it 9 years ago
2.5As many have said, the beginning of this little story was SUPER SUPER cute. Loved it. It was the rest of the story that didn't work for me. It felt like the first few pages of a novel or novella instead of a short story that could stand on its own. Perhaps there will be more written about this co...
The Tipsybibliophile
The Tipsybibliophile rated it 9 years ago
2.5 StarsThe beginning of this short was really cute, but I just didn't feel like I got much more information than what I already knew from the blurb.The premise was a bit of a stretch, but it could have still worked for me if I had felt that by the end I knew something about the characters. Even it...
Ami's Hoard
Ami's Hoard rated it 9 years ago
2.5 starsFeel like a party pooper among the glorious reviews here, but this one doesn't sell for me. I don't mind the fairy tale-ish idea, that's what happens with romantic movies too: serendipity, fairy tale ending, coincidences, well, I love that. The problem of this story for me is: 1) We have th...
Anke1028
Anke1028 rated it 9 years ago
3.5 * It was a cute, short read, although a bit too fairy-tale like for me.
Need help?