logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code
back to top
Search tags: Twenty-Trillion-Leagues-Under-the-Sea
Load new posts () and activity
Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
review 2015-03-29 07:59
Twenty Trillion Leagues Under The Sea
Twenty Trillion Leagues Under The Sea - Mahendra Singh,Adam Roberts

After reading this book, no-one will be able to deny the fact that's a weird book.

 

It's just so weird. During its first voyage the Plongeur, a French nuclear submarine, something goes horribly wrong. The vessel keeps sinking far past the depths that would normally crush the submarine. Far past the normal depth of the oceans.

 

One thing became painfully clear to me when reading this novel; I don't know enough about the classics. Because this is almost a retelling or an updated version of the original Jules Verne novel I suspect it's filled with references that I didn't get. Some things I googled and thus found, others will be lost forever on me. For that part I'm to blame.

 

But on the other hand, the story could never really hold my interest. It felt very long, even though the story itself wasn't that long (considered in pages). There are also 30 something pages filled with drawings that I didn't found that special. The ending was really lost on me (I suspect it might have been another reference). At the end, I was just glad the journey was over, for the crew as much as for me.

 

Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for providing me with a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!

Like Reblog Comment
review 2015-02-04 16:00
Twenty Trillion Leagues Under The Sea - Mahendra Singh,Adam Roberts

A fun but talky postmodern riff on Verne.  Recommended.

Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
review 2014-02-28 12:07
"Twenty Trillion Leagues Under the Sea" by Jules Verne (aka Adam Roberts...)
Twenty Trillion Leagues Under The Sea - Mahendra Singh,Adam Roberts

  Adam Roberts

 

2014 is going to be the year to read lots of new authors. Robert Adams was on my TBR pile since I can remember. Now was the time. Finally.

 

Having not read his previous work, I was just plain flabbergasted by this novel’s technical expertise.

 

The brain surely works in mysterious ways. While reading it, I kept thinking about Arthur C. Clarke. The same kind of narrative wonder is on display here. Unfortunately some problems make the novel less than totally enjoyable (see “Things that I did not like” below).

 

I sense that for Adam Roberts a lot of the appeal of science fiction isn't exactly in the science. It's in something that makes a leap. Like Asimov he seems to be fascinated by whodunits; in the SF field there are not many writers who have tried this approach, ie, to be able to devise clever whodunits set in a SF world. This novel is a clear signal of that. And it’s a quite clever whodunit.

 

Readers of a more traditional type of SF must look elsewhere. Adam likes to play with words and metaphors, which is something that’s not present in everyday-SF. Like Christopher Priest, Adam Roberts also tries to make a kind of rupture. To achieve that via conceptual jumps out of what we're familiar with is quite difficult. For me good SF must have the ability to estrange, and to make new. That’s what distinguished good from bad SF.

 

Also a very strong plus are the numerous interior illustrations by Mahendra Singh. It’s not easy to convey, at the same time, a sense of being both vintage and futuristic.

 

Drawing another parallel with “The Adjacent”, which can be clearly identified as SF, “Twenty Trillion Leagues Under the Sea” is not like anything you’ve ever read. It also seems to be traditional SF, but underneath it’s something else.

 

The things that I really liked: (1) the way the classical works of SF are used as a basis for the narrative; (2) the literary techniques

 

Things that I did not like: (1) some decisions seemed to lack internal justification, eg, why did the submarine on its maiden voyage took a 500-feet dive? (2) The crew seemed to be ill-prepared for the problems that arose.

 

If you put a five people in a room and they all read this book there would more than likely be five different interpretations of events. Adam Roberts manages to touch upon everything from politics and religion to the quest for ultimate knowledge and multi-verse theory. This is my type of story, when different readers will each take something different away from it.

More posts
Your Dashboard view:
Need help?