I wasn't sure if I should open with:
He went into the toilets again, just to steady his breathing and look at himself in the mirror. He tried to relax his jaw muscles. In the past, he'd have been reaching for the quarter-bottle of whisky in his pocket. But tonight there was no quarter-bottle, no Dutch courage. Which meant for once he'd be relying on the real thing.
...Rebus sat on a char in the interview room, watching his hands shaking.
'You OK?' Jack asked.
'Know what, Jack? You're like a broken record.'
'Know what, John? You're always needing it asked.'
Either one of those works to sum up Rebus' frame of mind in the latter half of this book (and that's largely because things had gotten worse for him by that point). Not that things were ever going his way in this book.
Following his gutsy political moves in the last book he's been assigned to the worst police station in Edinburgh and a case he worked early in his career as a Detective with his mentor has come under increased scrutiny thanks to some media attention, and an underdog convicted of that crime who is able to cast some doubt on the original investigation. Meanwhile, a serial killer from the late 60s (who remains uncaptured) has inspired a copycat. Rebus (like every detective in Scotland, it seems) is on the fringes of this investigation. Oh, yeah, and there's an unrelated suspicious death that Rebus needs to investigate.
Four cases, with more in common than anyone expects until the most tenacious cop east of Harry Bosch starts doing his thing. He starts following threads that take him far from his desk and home -- Glasgow and eventually Aberdeen -- and the oil platforms north. While dodging the press (more persistent that he's used to) superior officers and an internal investigation, Rebus moves around the country picking at clues and hunches while getting under the skin of criminals, cops, oil company executives, and one serial killer.
There are so many police officers running around this book, some we know, some we don't. Siobhan Clarke has a small, but pivotal role to play. Brian Holmes is around helping Rebus unofficially, while things with Nell are at their worst. Jack Morton, Rebus' old drinking pal plays a significant role in this novel -- he's clean and sober now, and is convinced that's what Rebus needs to do, too. Gil Templar needs Rebus' help, very unofficially. There are new detectives and from Glasgow, Aberdeen and Edinburgh for readers and Rebus to meet -- the main thing they all seem to have in common is that they don't want Rebus mucking around in their cities.
I don't know if I've seen Rebus more self-destructive. He's drinking more than normal (which is saying something) and seems to care less than ever about what his superiors think of him (which is also saying something). Some of his wry sense of humor remains -- almost entirely buried under cynicism. Rebus has had doubts about what he and his mentor did years ago, and the renewed attention isn't helping his sense of guilt. He is far more interested in the serial killer cases than he ought to be professionally, it's become a habit that threatens to distract him from his actual duties. His personal demons are almost as much of an antagonist than anyone he could possibly arrest in Black and Blue. Yet, he investigates in the same way he always does -- and the way he wraps up most of the cases carry his signature style.
Black and Blue is intense, it is ambitious -- for most of the book, it'd be easy to see this as being the end of the road for Rebus (if I wasn't fully aware that 13 other novels had been published with at least one more announced) -- not that you're all that worried about him living through the end, you're more worried that he'll be unemployed by the end. It's one of those novels that makes you want to ignore obligations, work and family -- none of which can be as interesting or pressing as the book. You could cut out half the murders from this novel and it'd still be a winner, including all of them makes this something more than that.
I went into this one with a mix of trepidation and anticipation -- I've heard that this was where the series took a turn for the better. I recently heard an interview with Rankin where he described it that way -- sales, awards, critical acclaim, all came with this book. So I was worried that I wouldn't see what so many had before -- but was excited to try. This one lives up to expectations, as high as they might be. Just a stunning work. I honestly don't know how Rankin will top this -- I'm not sure how easy it'll be to equal it.