Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code
back to top
Search tags: classic-noir
Load new posts () and activity
Like Reblog
show activity (+)
review 2017-09-17 11:33
The Thin Man-Buddy Read for Halloween Bingo 2017
The Thin Man - Dashiell Hammett

Lost my review twice now so I'm ready to spit nails.


I was happy to read the comments from those that did this buddy read. Other than that, if this is an example of Classic Noir, I don't think I'm going to be a fan. I didn't like anyone. The writing at times was hard to understand since it was written in another time and place. A couple of things I had to go and look up and realized it would have been better for me to just watch an old black and white movie instead.



"The Thin Man" follows Nick Charles, a former PI who is dragged into looking for a missing man he used to know, Clyde Wynant. Wynant goes missing after a former mistress/lover of his is found murdered. Clyde's terrible ass family shows up and asks him to find Clyde and or just act genuinely annoying. Someone else called them sociopaths in one of the updates and honestly I agree. 


Nick Charles is the main character in "The Thin Man." I assume the movies make him and Nora (his wife) more partner like. But besides Nora calming down people, ordering Nick food, and making Nick a drink, there wasn't much for her to do. Oh yeah, she laughed about her husband being flirted with right in front of her. 


The other characters are cringe worthy individuals. 


Mimi Wynant is a terrible mother to her two kids, Dorothy and Gilbert. She's obsessed with finding her ex husband to see what money she can shake out of him. In a crazy scene she loses it and goes incoherent with rage. She also beats her daughter and everyone acts like that's cool.



Dorothy is a low rent Lolita wannabe.


Gilbert is obsessed with his sister (yeah not in a good way) gives her drugs and talks about taking cocaine to make himself sharper. As one does.


There's the guy having an affair, but that's okay cause his wife is awful. Shakes head. 


Nick is thrown up against criminals and cops and finally announces who did it. I didn't follow the clues at all. So it was a surprise to me. 


The writing was typical of the 1930s. I didn't care for it much though. The flow was awful. It was just people drinking and shouting at each other. There's also a random story about cannibalism I'm still confused about including. 


The setting of New York during the Christmas holiday didn't feel realistic at all. Did any character mention cold or snow? New York during the last days of Prohibition should have been awesome as a setting.


The ending as I said was just a sad trombone sound come to life. Nick explains to Nora the who and the why. She argues with him, he ignores her, and they talk about New Year's Eve.


The end.

Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
text 2017-09-17 04:56
The Thin Man Progress Update: I've listened to 250 out of 355 minutes.


Okay, I made it past where Dorry asks Nick if her mamma is in love with him and we get that 'God no, she's a man hater' line. Then a few minutes later there's the ugly scene with Mimi. Whoa boy, so much crazy goin' on.  So I took a break and went looking for gifs.



Here's one for all you Nick lovers courtesy of Nora. ;)




Like Reblog
text 2017-09-17 02:12
Reading progress update: I've read 100%.
The Thin Man - Dashiell Hammett

I'll have to try Hammet's other works cause Nick and Nora Charles did not impress me at all.


The dialogue wasn't snappy to me. I was expecting more banter. 


Also how did anyone get anything done with the amount of booze they threw done their throats? 


At least I won't be forced to read about Dorothy and her constant crying about what happened to her when she was a kid anymore. 


Like Reblog
text 2017-09-17 01:14
Reading progress update: I've read 66%.
The Thin Man - Dashiell Hammett

All caught up now.


These people. Still awful.


“What did Mamma say—about me?”

“She said you’re in love with me.” 

She sat up abruptly. “What did you say?”

“I said you just liked me from when you were a kid.” 

Her lower lip twitched.

“Do—do you think that’s what it is?”

“What else could it be?”

“I don’t know.” She began to cry. “Everybody’s made so much fun about it—Mamma and Gilbert and Harrison—I—” 

I put my arms around her.

“To hell with them.” 

After a while she asked: “Is Mamma in love with you?”

“Good God, no! She hates men more than any woman I’ve ever known who wasn’t a Lesbian.”


Good grief. 


Like Reblog
text 2017-09-17 00:44
Reading progress update: I've read 56%.
The Thin Man - Dashiell Hammett

Lord. They are all awful.


That's all I got.


More posts
Your Dashboard view:
Need help?