At the moment of posting this my goodreads review for A COURT OF THORNS AND ROSES has 131 likes so it should appear on the second page of that site. That isn't the case and I wonder one more time for the reasons goodreads employees are trying to cover up the information and reviews that can help readers make informed decisions. My Tower of dawn review by this same author rhas been supressed from the first page of reviews even though it currently has 265 likes.
I also want to point out that this book portrays abusive relationships (Feyre and her older sisters, Feyre and her two love interests)and torture by one of the love interests. That isn't a reason for not reading the book, it's just something you should know as many booktubers and reviewers aren't commenting on these kind of problematic content. If that doesn't bother you I highly recommend this series. Please don't take my word for it, do your own research.
Here are the links to the reviews that were censored by goodreads team
My review will contain spoilers.
UPDATE APRIL 12TH ADDING PARENTAL GUIDANCE AND SAFETY WARNINGS because kirkus reviews, some GR librarians and most booktubers won't tell you the truth. This is a New adult book not as close to erotica as ACOMAF but still. I'm also changing my original 5 rating to a 3.5 rating
SEX/NUDITY 8 out 10 Descriptive make outs. Heroine is sleeping with a villager at the beginning of the book but it's not a graphic scene, some nudity descriptions, a graphic sex scene,including oral, between Tamlin and Feyre . Ritual sex is mentioned as part of a ceremony called Calanmai
VIOLENCE/GORE 7 out of 10 descriptions of torture to heroine, some of it by one of the love interests (Rhysand), a villager is burned alive during days because the villains mistook her for the heroine. The elder sisters of the heroine are emotionally abusive and unhelpful, they reap the benefits of heroine's sacrifices for themselves without lifting a finger.
PROFANITY 5/10 some curse words, some sexual references
SUBSTANCE USE 6/10 as every single character in this book is 19 or older or a milleneal ancient fae alcohol consumption is present. Mostly at meals and during a ceremony called Calanmai
SAFETY WARNINGS, possible spoilers for the rest of the series
In this series we have two heroes: Tamlin is the love interest in book 1 and he has sex with another woman after meeting the heroine because it's part of a certain FAE ceremony that keeps fae strong. They aren't together yet so it's not exactly cheating but that's the reason I didn't connect with Tamlin. Well the OW sex and the whole begging- on-his- knees- to- a -rival- for- the -heroine's -safety. That was just stupid.
In book 2 the love interest switches, Rhysand who appears as the villain in book 1 becomes love interest and Tamlin becomes a jerk, no one roots for Tamlin after chapter 4 because he acts stupidly. But we get a very graphic sex scene of heroine and Tamlin together at the beginning of A COURT OF MIST AND FURY. As someone who is team rhysand I didn't enjoy that sex scene. I got very happy with the rest of the book because Tamlin dissapears and later there's a lot of sex with Rhysand, but yeah, this is an unsafe read.
So my original rating changes to 3.5 I can't rate lower in spite of the safety issues because book 2 is one of my all time favourites.
It was difficult to read the first half or so of this book because the protagonist (Seth) and his best (and only) friend (Carter) are aggravatingly ignorant of their appropriation of black culture. They're even more offensive for thinking they're woke or genuine in their fetishistic consumption of the rarest blues, at least in Carter's case. Seth is less than sympathetic in his own distinct way; he's such a follower that he barely has a personality of his own. As little as I could bear the privileged Carter, Seth is consequently even harder for me to care about given that he follows Carter like a puppy. I don't know what to make of the fact that both have or have had mental health issues. And I don't know what to make of Seth's thing for Carter's sister.
I patiently waited for these guys to get some sort of comeuppance. When it came, it was a whirlwind of genres, a mishmash of past and present, a blurring of identities. Formally, stylistically, this novel took off, grabbing me by the collar. It was hard to put down. I hadn't known what to expect at the beginning, which is a gift for a reader. I do think at times the cues or signals were overdone; we could have been better trusted to follow the shifts in time and perspective. But what a ride.
My house is a mess. My studio (sometimes called "the little house," because that's what it is) is a disaster. The workshop is worse than both of the others combined.
I have five weeks until the spring Studio Tour, which is the last show event of the season. Scheduling conflicts forced me to cancel participation in two other shows, which wasn't good for my bottom line. This spring Tour is a new event for our artists group, and I'm very excited about it.
Today was the first opportunity I've had to really plunge into work for it, however. We've either had weather too cold to work in either the shop or the studio, or I've had other events going on. And to tell the truth, I just haven't had the energy. Part of that may have been due to the vitamin D deficiency diagnosed last month; after a month's worth of supplements, maybe that's been turned around, too. At any rate, I was up by 6:00 this morning, threw in a load of laundry and dashed to the grocery store for a few essentials while the washer was running. I was home before the final rinse.
And then it was out to the studio to start cleaning some of the mess. I actually made some progress, and when it got warm enough outside, I even ventured over to the workshop.
I have to confess I almost turned around and walked back out, but I gathered up some determination and headed for the storage racks where the 80+ plastic shoeboxes of rocks are stored.
Over the years, some of those plastic boxes have rotted from the sun and started to disintegrate, making a horrible mess. That had to be today's first chore, and it involved sorting out the rocks in those boxes. As almost always happens when I dig into boxes of rocks that I've had for a long time, I discover things I didn't know I had, either because I just plain forgot about them or because I didn't know what they were in the first place.
One of those sun-rotted boxes had a whole bunch of Oregon beach agates, some already polished and some not. I sorted out a batch for the tumbler and got them started; they should be finished just in time for the Studio Tour.
Feeling proud of myself for having actually accomplished something, I began rearranging some other things in the workshop. Most of the boxes of (uninventoried) books are at least labeled by genre, but there are other boxes containing . . . . heaven only knows what. One of them happened to be in the way of the area I was cleaning, so I opened it to see if the contents were even worth messing around with.
I laughed out loud.
A whole box of gothic romances. At least 50, maybe 75, maybe more. I grabbed the Norah Lofts and Georgette Heyer from the top layer, but there's a whole lot more. Willo Davis Roberts. Dorothy Eden. Now I can't even remember who all else.
I've already added my edition of Penhallow to the database. I'll add Copsi Castle in a few minutes. If only I didn't have to take time out to cook supper!
When I wrote The Looking-Glass Portrait, I knew exactly what the inspiration was: the house. I detailed the background here via a link to my blog here. The story kind of came to me separately -- and remember, it started 20+ years before it ended -- but the house was the focus when I structured the plot.
This certainly is no great revelation: the gothic genre began with The Castle of Otranto, so the tradition has been there from the beginning. As we've seen here on BookLikes with buddy reads of Jamaica Inn and Ammie, Come Home, houses and other dwelling places continue to be integral to the genre. There are ghosts, but they are connected to houses.
Sometimes the houses end up destroyed, as happened to Manderley, in Rebecca. But even then, even in its destruction, Manderley exercised its power over the second Mrs. de Winter.
The house in Edison Park, Illinois that served as the model for LGP, is still there. Another house I'd love to put into a gothic romance is long gone. I was told it, like Manderley, burned to the ground 25 or more years ago.
My paternal grandparents also lived in Edison Park, but they moved from there to Roselle, Illinois, a western suburb in DuPage County, in the very early 1950s. So early in the 1950s that I have no real memories of their home on Owen Avenue at all. They lived in Roselle until 1966, however, so I have clear recollections of that house.
The original house was small, just one bedroom, one bath, kitchen, and a big living/dining room. The latter had an open, beamed ceiling.
There was a big open covered porch, and another closed-in porch that led to the dining room. French doors opened from the single bedroom onto the porch, too.
I don't remember the front door at all.
Shortly after moving into the house, my grandparents began installing a fireplace, a mammoth fieldstone structure that replaced the front door. My dad, my grandfather, and my dad's cousin Bob built the fireplace, cementing stones from the yard of the 2-acre property in place.
When the fireplace was finished, my grandmother hung Bells of Sarna from the huge wooden mantel. I loved those bells; I would be allowed to jingle them once or twice each time we visited. I have no idea what happened to them, but years ago I purchased a strand of my own. They hang in my living room now.
I don't have many photos of the interior of the house, and the few I have of the exterior are from my grandparents' earliest occupancy. Along with the fireplace, they built a larger addition on the east end of the house with two large bedrooms, a shower bath, basement and attic. I "borrowed" the pull-down stairs to the attic for LGP, since the Edison Park house didn't have any.
The house sat at the top of a low hill, with a long, winding gravel driveway down to the road, Forest Avenue.
I loved the trees, mostly oaks and shagbark hickories. There was one crabapple tree. The old horse-drawn plow was rusted and stuck in the hard clay ground, but I thought it was fabulous, a romantic relic.
Though I can't find it in these photos, there was a huge pink granite boulder somewhere in the yard. It was absolutely enormous, to my two- or three-year-old self. Best of all, however, it had a "saddle" on the top, a naturally broken out dip that was perfect for a little girl of the suburbs to imagine, there in that big open yard, that she had a horse.
There were other people in the neighborhood who did have horses, though I didn't see them often. Years later, when I was in high school and bored with being around the family members, I'd go for long walks to catch a glimpse of a horse here or there, or to visit the dogs at the two collie kennels a street or two over. One of the fences keeping the dogs in bore a sign identifying the owners as The Pettigrews. Yeah, I stole the name, too.
But that big pink rock was so special. As I grew up, I was eventually able to climb onto it myself, and then even jump over it. Yet in my memory it remained gigantic.
I'm not sure when it was, but I was visiting the family years ago and decided to take a drive out to Roselle to see the place. My dad had told me the house had burned down, but I still wanted to go out there. It was winter; there was snow on the ground, I remember that much. And there was a new house at the top of the hill. But at the bottom of the driveway, half covered by snow plowed off the road, was the big pink rock.
And it was so, so, so much smaller than I remembered!
A couple of years ago, while I was doing the online research of old family houses, I swooped down on a Google Maps street view and went digitally driving down Forest Avenue to see what I could see.
Is that the big pink rock? Or what's left of it? I don't know. But I like to think it is.
P.S. When my grandparents sold the house in 1966, the following ad appeared in the local newspaper: