logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

The Facts In The Case Of The Departure Of Miss Finch - Community Reviews back

by Michael Zulli, Neil Gaiman
sort by language
I Live in Many Worlds
I Live in Many Worlds rated it 9 years ago
If you've been following my reviews for a while, you'll know how much I adore Neil Gaiman's children literature. I've read nearly all the books he's written for kids and loved each one of them. I have yet to read his adult fiction, but I plan to rectify that within the coming months. However, I have...
LeahSL
LeahSL rated it 14 years ago
So... what the heck was the smoke monster? In other words, this was an enjoyable experience with a frustrating lack of answering questions. Not that this is surprising: if getting Joss'ed means a beloved character is killed off for no damn reason, Gaiman'ed is going "ooooh awesome...but WHY???".
Title and Statement of Responsibility
Very light on substance, but entertaining.
StaceyHH
StaceyHH rated it 14 years ago
Well. I adore Gaiman, will read or listen to nearly anything he's done, and in fact am still catching up on some of his smaller works and short stories. The version of this story that appeared in Smoke and Mirrors just seems more cohesive. In this graphic novel version, the story feels disjointed an...
Ceridwen
Ceridwen rated it 14 years ago
This book is a totally unnecessary and almost belittling graphic version of one of Gaiman's least affecting short stories. I picked it up from the library, because that is cheaper than shelling out the fifteen bucks for a hardcover version, and that is the only reason I'm not slapping this with one ...
Need help?