logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

A Secret Kept - Community Reviews back

by Tatiana de Rosnay
sort by language
Rabbit Reads
Rabbit Reads rated it 10 years ago
Rating: 3.5? I still don't know how I feel. There were things I loved about the book but things I loathed as well. Review to come. Edit: I decided to rate this a solid 3 stars. The MC was such an unlikeable douche. Just the misogyny and the slut-shaming of a teenage girl. YUCK. I am not sure if we a...
cczarneckikernus
cczarneckikernus rated it 12 years ago
Not quite as good as Sarah's Key, but still really liked it.
Get Lost in the Stacks
Get Lost in the Stacks rated it 12 years ago
Could just not get into it, which makes me sad since I loved Sarah's Key
Kristin Reads
Kristin Reads rated it 13 years ago
Wasn't as good as Sarah's Key but it was an interesting read none the less!
Chris' Fish Place
Chris' Fish Place rated it 13 years ago
So I'm giving this the same rating that I gave Sarah's Key. It's not a bad book. It's a bit too predictable, a bit too Lifetime or Hallmark movie. The mystery or the secret is really easy to figure out. It reminded me of those movies from the 70s. You know like The Towering Inferno; a bit moral...
EeeJay
EeeJay rated it 14 years ago
DNF - very boring retro-spective book. Meh
Coffee Bean Bookshelf
Coffee Bean Bookshelf rated it 14 years ago
I'm not really sure what I think of this book...it wasn't as good as Sarah's Key. You were sucked into this book by the premise of some big secret, something big enough to cause emotional distress and a car accident. But there wasn't anything. There was this ONE secret that is let out halfway thr...
JulieM
JulieM rated it 14 years ago
For Melanie's 40th birthday, her brother Antoine takes her on a surprise visit to Nourmoutier Island where the 2 had spent many summer vacations as children. But not only does the weekend bring back many happy family memories, Melanie recalls a family secret that had been forgotten. On the drive b...
That's What She Read
That's What She Read rated it 14 years ago
A Secret Kept makes much of the secret about Clarisse, Antoine and Mélanie's mother; however, at heart it is a novel about relationships - father, brother, son, lover, husband, employee and even mother and sister. How does each relationship change over time? What does each role owe another? The fami...
Thewanderingjew
Thewanderingjew rated it 14 years ago
First, I would like to remark about the cover of the book. There is a woman walking down a street. The stark contrast of her wide, red flaring coat against the narrow cobble-stoned almost colorless road, was beautiful and evoked memories of the child in the red coat against a black and white backgro...
Need help?