logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Ash - Community Reviews back

by Malinda Lo
sort by language
Sai Marie's Sultry Stanzas
Sai Marie's Sultry Stanzas rated it 6 years ago
Loved this story, a fresh fairytale with familiarity and a sensuous style that swept me away into a world of thrilling and luxurious fantasy, I finished it in one day.
Momster Bookworm
Momster Bookworm rated it 9 years ago
A twisted fairy tale based upon 'Cinderella'.
Hey Ashers!
Hey Ashers! rated it 9 years ago
Spoiler Rating: High Hey Katie, I won't lie; I rushed through Ash years ago, and didn't particularly like it. It was marketed to me as a lesbian Cinderella story, and if there are two things that'll perk my ears up, it's lesbian characters and Cinderella stories. So I settled down with Ash and a...
The Symmetrical Bookworm
The Symmetrical Bookworm rated it 10 years ago
You have no idea how much I wanted to love Ash. I mean, a Cinderella retelling where Cinderella (Ash) is a lesbian? Count me in! For sure!For such an interesting and original premise, Ash was pretty dull. Pretty much NOTHING happens throughout the whole book. There is no conflict that has to be reso...
Emerjas
Emerjas rated it 10 years ago
When Ash's father dies, she finds herself the servant of her stepmother and stepsisters. Her only comfort are the fairy tales her mother used to read her as a child. Ash's best hope for getting out of her situation is to be taken by the fairies, and when she meets the fairy Sidhean, it looks like he...
FatherCraneMadeMeDoIt
FatherCraneMadeMeDoIt rated it 11 years ago
Like a lot of the other reviews of this book, I had really high expectations after reading what it was about, but the novel ultimately fell short. I am not much into fairy tales, but the idea of "Cinderella" not choosing the prince and falling in love with a woman instead was pretty appealing to me....
Oliviate
Oliviate rated it 11 years ago
Malinda Lo's lovely lesbian YA Ash is a romantic and lyrical retelling of Cinderella with two female protagonists. Yet the structure of the world is very focused on straight marriage as a means of property transfer and means of producing heirs.
macaruchi
macaruchi rated it 11 years ago
I almost didn't read this book because it had fairies (I don't like them). I like my fantasy stories to have dragons, magic, death, blood, but this book had none of that, however, I really loved this story, I never got bored, on the contrary, I couldn't put the book down, and here I am, at 1:30am on...
Bibliophilia
Bibliophilia rated it 11 years ago
I finally have gotten around to reading this much recommended book. I like it. It's done a difficult thing; making the various "Cinderella" tales (http://www.pitt.edu/~dash/type0510a.html) new. It's also rather subtle. This one's a keeper for me. And I'll be looking for more by Lo.
Confessions of a Bibliophile
Confessions of a Bibliophile rated it 11 years ago
While I’m a sucker for retellings and an even bigger fan of fairy tale retellings/reworkings/updates/continuations/spins/what have you, I do come into said things with a caveat—what does the author do to make this their own? Which is hard, and I acknowledge that. Taking a story and characters that a...
Need help?