logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Batman: Noel - Community Reviews back

by Lee Bermejo
sort by language
fossumcarl
fossumcarl rated it 11 years ago
An unusual odd batman story exquisitely drawn.
The Holy Terror
The Holy Terror rated it 11 years ago
A Batman Christmas Carol
brandonsears
brandonsears rated it 12 years ago
I have a slight obsession with Christmas. No, I’m not the kind that advocates that you keep Christ in Christmas or even the kind of guy who goes to church once a year on Christmas Eve. In fact, I’m not religious in the slightest. What I’m all about are the Christmas specials, the movies, the musi...
Breaking It All Down
Breaking It All Down rated it 12 years ago
This is a pretty good Christmas story, but making Batman like Scrooge in this fashion just doesn't quite work.
Sesana
Sesana rated it 13 years ago
I'm working off a fuzzy memory here, but I'm pretty sure I've already read another Batman version of A Christmas Carol. I feel like Sale was involved. If so, this isn't even a new idea for Batman, never mind the fact that doing a version of A Christmas Carol is just as cliched as doing a version of ...
Ironic Contradictions
Ironic Contradictions rated it 13 years ago
I don't normally give graphic novels five stars. Those which are near among the best for me often receive four stars at most. However this was so superiorly superb that I had to give it five stars.The storyline was a clever twist on the typical Batman storyline. It featured an overlying narration of...
Tower of Iron Will
Tower of Iron Will rated it 13 years ago
Bermejo is possibly the best artist working in comics today and with Batman: Noel he proves he can write as well. It is a very clever conceit, retelling Dickens' Christmas Carol with Batman as Scrooge, Robin as Jacob Marley, Catwoman as the Ghost of Christmas Past, Superman as Christmas Present, an...
pedestrienne
pedestrienne rated it 13 years ago
is this the reason that songs from the Muppet Christmas Carol were in my head this weekend?
pedestrienne
pedestrienne rated it 13 years ago
is this the reason that songs from the Muppet Christmas Carol were in my head this weekend?
Erutane
Erutane rated it 13 years ago
The story is somewhat sensibly linked to A Christmas Carol through Batman's miserly dominance over the down-on-their-luck-turned-criminals of Gotham, but the cornball ending made it pure mush. Of course, it is the spectacularly detailed art that has impressed me. Lee Bermejo should undeniably illust...
Need help?