logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Earthsong - Community Reviews back

by Suzette Haden Elgin, Julie Vedder
sort by language
All the Time in the World
All the Time in the World rated it 14 years ago
A gross disappointment after Native Tongue. I suspect Ms. Elgin didn't have much of a plan for the "long game" when she wrote NT, and how she resolved her story in this third volume turned out to be not very satisfying. I re-read Native Tongue and The Judas Rose periodically, but don't even curren...
Amadan na Briona
Amadan na Briona rated it 31 years ago
I really didn't like this as much as the first two books in the trilogy. Whereas they had a plot, this third book was really more a collection of short stories, with little to tie them together. Frankly, it was neither very well edited nor very entertaining, and was missing the thought-provoking ide...
Need help?