logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

El Club de la Buena Estrella - Community Reviews back

by Jordi Fibla, Amy Tan
sort by language
Bookish Blerd
Bookish Blerd rated it 7 years ago
So, I hate when I keep books on my 'TBR' list for so long that I regret waiting so long to read them. I loved the movie, so I knew the book would be even better. After having read the book, it is better (of course), but doesn't take away from the movie. This is a book about mothers and daughters...
Fangirl Moments and My Two Cents
Fangirl Moments and My Two Cents rated it 8 years ago
This is mothers and daughters telling their stories. They don't really know each other. This is the real them. Beliefs and traditions play a part. Some went through so much. A lot of what happens is sad. I don't think I took the time with this book that is necessary with each of their stories....
Reading Slothfully
Reading Slothfully rated it 8 years ago
A story about four Chinese women and their daughters. The women were all born in China and grew up there. Their daughters were all born in America. How were they different, how the same? How did they intrinsically understand each other and how not? Along the way, we learn something about the culture...
A Man With An Agenda
A Man With An Agenda rated it 10 years ago
This is a story of mothers and daughters, immigration and what being and becoming American means. Its a novel about China. It shouldn't be tucked away in those niches, though. 'The Joy Luck Club' moved me and opened my eyes to a set of experiences I hadn't given much thought to. I have a tendency to...
rameau's ramblings
rameau's ramblings rated it 10 years ago
There's only one fatal flaw in this wonderfully written novel about eight Chinese-American women and that flaw is its seven first person voice narrators. Let me repeat that: Seven narrators who all sound the same. The three living mothers and four daughters tell stories of their childhood, stories o...
KizunaYueMichaelis
KizunaYueMichaelis rated it 11 years ago
Sometimes the story dragged a little bit, and in fact, the main problem was the difficulty to differentiate a mother from the other, a daughter from the other. There were some good stories, other were kind of MEH. It is not hard to identify oneself with each daughter and how they feel about their mo...
Bloodorange
Bloodorange rated it 11 years ago
I read this book some 15 years ago, and had no memory of reading it, which I found unusual, and was actually quite glad when I found I would have to reread it for a student's project. And how hard that was!I know, I KNOW I should have liked this book more. I know it was - and is - important, and it ...
Crash My Book Party
Crash My Book Party rated it 11 years ago
The Joy Luck Club is another one of those books I've been meaning to read for ages, but without really knowing anything about it, and have finally gotten around to it after buying a slightly battered copy from an op shop (for $1!). The Joy Luck Club is a beautiful and tragic and interesting collecti...
Reading with cats
Reading with cats rated it 12 years ago
Whiney, petulant characters; no plot; characters indistinguishable from each other.
Lavinia
Lavinia rated it 12 years ago
I just love it when I start a book with no expectations and end up loving it. Which is rare, since I usually do have expectations. It was the mother-daughter thing that got me interested, but I ended up loving it for so many reasons: Tan's style and talent as a story teller, the symmetry (everything...
Need help?