logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

El Guardián Spanish Translation - Community Reviews back

by Mary Calmes, Jorge Medina
sort by language
Trisha Harrington's Blog
Trisha Harrington's Blog rated it 10 years ago
Um... Yeah, I'm not really sure how to rate this yet. So I'll leave it for now and see how I feel later.
Chibishichan1x2
Chibishichan1x2 rated it 12 years ago
1.5, essentially I agree with what the review from Midnight says
MostlyDelores
MostlyDelores rated it 12 years ago
Re-read for the second time. This now reads as a very early, more amateurish work compared to her other books. It is, I think, the only story in third person, and the POV hopping is choppy to say the least. If she were to write it now (or edit it for re-release), it would be much smoother. Having sa...
julio-alexi genao
julio-alexi genao rated it 12 years ago
Boy, this was rough. So much packed into it, it really should have been a multi-volume epic. Herky-jerky and slapdash, but still rewarding.
Mandy, I read obsessively
Mandy, I read obsessively rated it 12 years ago
3.5*Typical Mary Calmes story, beautiful wonderful, loved by everyone MC and his über -man guardian from another realm, who sees him and knows he is his heart and there's a small war to be waged against baddies, and of course Super MC protects little love by sending him home to wait for him....six m...
Bea's Reading Den
Bea's Reading Den rated it 13 years ago
I have to say that this author knows how to create an intriguing world. I loved the character of Jude. He is someone that we all can relate. He does not know his own appeal and folks just want to be with him.Now, that being said, I did feel like the ending was rushed. This book could easily been...
Romances and more...
Romances and more... rated it 13 years ago
three stars. I found this book to be good. It has the fame feels as her other novels, but the medieval aspect threw me a little.
bleeper
bleeper rated it 14 years ago
2.5
Msmiz - I read almost anything!
Msmiz - I read almost anything! rated it 14 years ago
I love this story. Mary Calmes knows how to write one hell of a story.
Author Amanda Young Says
Author Amanda Young Says rated it 15 years ago
I really wanted to like this story. I absolutely loved the other stories I've read by Mary Calmes. Unfortunately, I just couldn't sink my teeth into this one. Nevertheless, I'll keep an eye out for her next story and hope this was just a fluke for me.
Need help?