logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Karl Marlantes - Community Reviews back

sort by language
Just Another Reader
Just Another Reader rated it 10 years ago
Okay. This was a heavy (emotions wise) book. Written by a former marine who fought in Vietnam and that he's been trying to publish for 30 years, it does not pull any punches. None. Granted, I have never been in war or any branches of the military. So I really have no idea how realistic it is. But i...
Expendable Mudge Muses Aloud
Expendable Mudge Muses Aloud rated it 11 years ago
Newly Tarted Up Review! I...well...honestly, I have no idea what word to use to describe how I feel about MATTERHORN by Karl Marlantes. It's a superlative book, no adjectives need apply. I gave it five stars because that's the scale...but it deserves six. http://tinyurl.com/q89t7b2
The Tipsybibliophile
The Tipsybibliophile rated it 12 years ago
This book gave me an entirely different perspective about war and what the men and women who fight them really experience.I have deep respect and empathy for the young men and women from all over the world who make incredible sacrifices sometimes sacrificing their own lives to fight wars, our wars.K...
The Aussie Zombie
The Aussie Zombie rated it 12 years ago
I would probably never read Matterhorn if it wasn't for a group on Goodreads that had several members raving about how despite the fact they aren't the biggest fan of war stories, they loved Matterhorn. And it's not that I don't love war stories, I've just had bad luck in the past with stories that ...
UNICORN PORN FOR ALL
UNICORN PORN FOR ALL rated it 12 years ago
I'm not seeing the fuss here. The writing is pretty clunky and the characters are just archetypes. The story goes through all the familiarly horrific beats you're used to if you've seen a bunch of Vietnam movies already. There are a bunch of obvious hoo-rah scenes. It certainly moves - for all its l...
Chrissie's Books
Chrissie's Books rated it 12 years ago
On completion:I have written my thoughts as I progressed through this audiobook, so this will be just a short summary. As is evident from the comments below, when I began this book it caused me lots of trouble. I had trouble understanding the military jargon and acronyms. I had trouble keeping track...
Michelle Scott, urban fantasy author
Michelle Scott, urban fantasy author rated it 12 years ago
Stationed in the thick of the Vietnam War, the Marines in Bravo Company do what good soldiers always do - follow orders and try to survive.This was one of the most compelling books I've read this year. Although I typically don't read this genre, I was immediately hooked by the stories of these men....
"Check Six"
"Check Six" rated it 12 years ago
It was so good it hurt. Really good. Matterhorn makes it clear you will NEVER understand what it is like to go to war, unless you are one of the warriors in the fight. But he will drag you into a world that seems so immediate and real, you will come out drained. It took him 30 years to write the sto...
JeffreyKeeten
JeffreyKeeten rated it 13 years ago
"Just below the grim tranquillity Mellas had learned to display, he cursed with boiling intensity the ambitious men who used him and his troops to further their careers. He cursed the air wing for not trying to get any choppers in through the clouds. He cursed the diplomats arguing about round and s...
Damn Good Books (or not)
Damn Good Books (or not) rated it 13 years ago
This book is gripping. It won't let you go. It is also sad, sad, sad. It's not easy to read for those of us who lived through this time. It's about war in all it's toughness, it's dirt and muck and death, what it does to the souls' of men, and why we must find some way to advance beyond the "...
Need help?