logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Nad propastyu vo rzhi roman, povesti, rasskazy - Community Reviews back

by J.D. Salinger
sort by language
Sheila's Reads
Sheila's Reads rated it 8 years ago
I understand why you should not read this for the first time as an adult but my education was neglected in my teens, obviously, since I did not read it then. Holden is a pain where the sun don't shine. He is so whiny. He acts as if he's seen everything, done everything, and knows everything but, ...
las lecturas de Eme
las lecturas de Eme rated it 9 years ago
It's true that I didn't remember the book this way. Maybe I was too young the first time I read it, but certainly there were things I needed to live to fully understand it.However, I didn't quite like it the first time... and still didn't quite like it this one. I feel Holden's pain about some thing...
Malin
Malin rated it 9 years ago
This review will contain spoilers, so if you want to avoid knowing all the details of the sparse and meaningless plot, maybe skip the first couple of paragraphs. Holden Caulfield is a self-important, spoiled and worthless little shit. At the start of the book, he is cooling his heels at the fourt...
Jocelyn (The Reading World)
Jocelyn (The Reading World) rated it 9 years ago
Going to have to separate the artist from the art here. I know that Catcher was a deeply personal book to Salinger, but that doesn't change the fact that it was immensely dull to read.In theory, this should have appealed to me, according to the vast majority of the readers who consider it an endurin...
Abandoned by Booklikes
Abandoned by Booklikes rated it 9 years ago
I honestly don't know where to begin with this mess of a novel. It was repetitive and boring. The main character had his head up his own ass through this entire book, which is not surprising since he is a teenager. I know that I was supposed to probably sit around afterwards and discuss how profound...
a Girl Who Reads
a Girl Who Reads rated it 9 years ago
a great story ! Holden Caulfield is a unique character. a kid dissatisfied with everything and everyone around him. He tells the events and thoughts of what he experienced in days after he gets kicked out of his school for bad grades. i liked the way how he saw people and the honesty in it. He poin...
Reader & Dreamer
Reader & Dreamer rated it 9 years ago
wow a great story ! Holden Caulfield is a unique character. a kid dissatisfied with everything and everyone around him. He tells the events and thoughts of what he experienced in days after he gets kicked out of his school for bad grades. i liked the way how he saw people and the honesty in it. He ...
Read & Breathe
Read & Breathe rated it 10 years ago
I had to read this book for school two years ago and was not able to get through it because of how bad it was and I didn't have enough time to push myself to finish it. I decided to retry it now because I figured it could not be as bad as I remembered. It was not, it was even worse. Holden is the m...
The Caffeinated Diva reads...
The Caffeinated Diva reads... rated it 10 years ago
I picked up this book for the Eclectic Reader Challenge and it ended up doing double duty as a read for a module on censorship and banning in a lit class I am taking this semester. It is one of those "Life List" books that I never read in high school but felt like I should. The novel is a Holden C...
The Caffeinated Diva reads...
The Caffeinated Diva reads... rated it 10 years ago
I picked up this book for the Eclectic Reader Challenge and it ended up doing double duty as a read for a module on censorship and banning in a lit class I am taking this semester. It is one of those "Life List" books that I never read in high school but felt like I should. The novel is a Holden ...
Need help?