logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Return of the Dapper Men - Community Reviews back

by Jim McCann, Janet K. Lee
sort by language
What Perry Nodelman Is Reading, and Has Read.
Pretentious pseudo-philosophical whimsy about how men who dress well can awaken dead souls, give people the time of day, and teach everyone how to dream their dreams. Over complex and yet somehow under-drawn illustrations, in which supposedly non-creepy characters have no irises or pupils. As a wis...
Bibliobimbo
Bibliobimbo rated it 13 years ago
I hate to admit it, but this is one of those books that makes me feel stupid, because I think there's a whole layer of the story I'm missing. I got the references to Shakespeare, and the nursery rhymes, but who were the Dapper Men supposed to be? Why were there 314 of them? Why was 41 different? Why...
Sesana
Sesana rated it 13 years ago
There's no question that Return of the Dapper Men is beautiful. The art is often stunning, in fact, and I'd highly recommend it for just the art alone. The writing, however, left me cold. It is, I think, overexplained, in a way that doesn't trust the lovely art to do its part of the storytelling. Th...
Jessica (HDB)
Jessica (HDB) rated it 14 years ago
I've been in a graphic novel loving mood lately, and so I decided to try out something new. Generally what I read is dark, gritty and realistic. So why not take a step back and read something a little more light and fun? When I saw the cover of Return of the Dapper Men I instantly knew it was someth...
Kaethe
Kaethe rated it 14 years ago
So cool. The art is pretty amazing, and I really enjoyed the extra at the end explaining Lee's process. I'm not sure I got the story's point, it's kind of beautifully metaphorical, but the package is gorgeous.Library copy
Need help?