logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Suzy McKee Charnas - Community Reviews back

sort by language
Carolyn Cannot Live Without Books!
Carolyn Cannot Live Without Books! rated it 10 years ago
Anthology. I didn't read them all and I skipped a couple, so my rating is based only on the stories I read. 3.2 stars average. 1. A Bird that Whistles by Emma Bull. A music mentor with something different and a life lesson (?) I liked the story. 3-1/2 stars2. Make a Joyful Noise by Charles de Lint. ...
we were young and naive still
we were young and naive still rated it 12 years ago
I read only The Coldest Girl in Coldtown and therefore my starring only applies to the aforementioned story.
willaful
willaful rated it 12 years ago
I enjoyed most of what I read of this book, but thought it very funny that a book with an entire section for paranormal romance, including a freakin' essay, got it completely wrong. One out of the eight stories ("Seeing Eye" by Patricia Briggs) was paranormal romance. The rest strongly leaned toward...
Bitsy's Books
Bitsy's Books rated it 12 years ago
Overall: 2.5 StarsI'm burnt out on vampires for the foreseeable future, but since I've made it my quest to read everything Catherynne Valente has ever written, I just read the stories of authors who I like/am interested in. Sadly, out of the stories I read, the only story worth reading was Valente'...
Maybe Tomorrow
Maybe Tomorrow rated it 12 years ago
Not sure if it's my poor attention span and distraction causing me issues (read: yeah, it probably is), but I just couldn't get into many of these short stories at all.
catherinehaines
catherinehaines rated it 12 years ago
Best stories: "Things To Know About Being Dead" by Genevieve Valentine, "The List of Definite Endings" by Kaaron Warren, "Best Friends Forever" by Cecil Castellucci, "Transition" by Melissa Marr, "Vampire Weather" by Garth Nix and "Sit the Dead" by Jeffrey Ford.
sfgale
sfgale rated it 13 years ago
Yeah, i enjoyed this when all's said and done. The first section of the book(mythic fiction) very much let down the second and third sections which really would have lifted this book into the 5 star realms had they been the whole of the book. Still, very good on the whole. In any anthology there are...
suzemo
suzemo rated it 13 years ago
There were two stories I liked in this book, and the rest just bored me (which was disappointing, because I like so many of the authors featured). Maybe it was because the book is a young-adult book and many of them are centered around angsty teens. I don't know, but I couldn't care about most of ...
Sesana
Sesana rated it 13 years ago
The unifying concept of this collection is that each story is supposed to be inspired by something written by Poe, a specific story or poem instead of his style in general. I do feel a little bad about only giving this book two stars. There are 19 stories collected here, but only three that I enjoye...
Writing and Reading and Editing, O My!
Full review up on Green Man Review: http://greenmanreview.com/books/beagle-and-lansdale-the-urban-fantasy-anthology/
Need help?