Ms. Yoder incorporates a tragedy in her childhood to wheel in added scenes about the Englisch babysitter that doesn't want widower Nathan Miller to marry. Schoolteacher, Abby Yoder, has walked into a trap, but she doesn't see it, for she is in love with handsome Amish cowboy, Nathan Miller. As a record blizzard approaches quaint Millersburg, Ohio, can Nathan arrange to have Abby snowed in at his place, like he's done with the previous five schoolteachers over the past five years. She is the sixth schoolteacher, but she is tugging his heart-strings and smoothing out his edges. Will a dark secret behind silvery snowflakes bring them together or further apart?