logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

The Bards of Bone Plain - Community Reviews back

by Patricia A. McKillip
sort by language
By Singing Light
By Singing Light rated it 10 years ago
url
Note: Throughout July, I’ll be re-reading and reviewing books by Patricia McKillip. While I don’t think there are any huge spoilers below, I can’t swear that there are none, so tread with caution if that’s something you’re concerned about. The Bards of Bone Plain is one of Patricia McKillip’s most...
Allusion is not Illusion
Allusion is not Illusion rated it 11 years ago
Patricia, I'm going to have to put my foot down: I know you looove the idea of harpers/bards/minstrels, but enough already. One author can only write so many stories about bards before it becomes a little embarrassing. And repetitive. Hey, I still enjoyed your book, but I did skip all those long pas...
MK's Reading Life
MK's Reading Life rated it 12 years ago
Enjoyable as she always is, but this one felt incomplete. Her books, post-Riddlemaster, have spoken to me of deeper meanings, not strictly allegory, but more using myth to explore this life. I don't mind working a little harder to find it, but I seem to have missed it completely with this one. I did...
B. Morris Allen
B. Morris Allen rated it 13 years ago
Patricia McKillip almost always tells the same story - a talented, bemused character is mystified by something that may or may not be magic, and tries to understand its heart. Even the fabulous Riddle-Master of Had is a variant on this. When she strays a bit (Moon-Flash, Cygnet), she's been less suc...
altheaann
altheaann rated it 13 years ago
McKillip is a master of combining romantic, poetic description with humor and realism, and in Bards of Bone Plain, as usual, she achieves a perfect balance.The novel meshes two stories, set several hundred years apart. I love that both time periods have a realistic sense of history, of both past and...
crownoflaurel
crownoflaurel rated it 14 years ago
There was nothing I did not enjoy about this book. I'm really beginning to adore this author.
wealhtheow
wealhtheow rated it 14 years ago
In the nation of Beldan, the princess prefers archaeology to balls, and the roads are traversed by steam-powered horseless carriages. After the princess digs up a strange coin, her friend Phelan begins finding other clues that the riddles and songs he's spent his life memorizing might be magical......
By Singing Light
By Singing Light rated it 14 years ago
I like the setting, which is an unusual one for McKillip. It seems more 19th century without--and this is excellent--getting all steampunky (not that there’s anything wrong with steampunk, just that I don’t think it would mix well with McKillip). The characters were also quite delightful. [Feb. 2011...
Allusion is not Illusion
Allusion is not Illusion rated it 14 years ago
Patricia, I'm going to have to put my foot down: I know you looove the idea of harpers/bards/minstrels, but enough already. One author can only write so many stories about bards before it becomes a little embarrassing. And repetitive. Hey, I still enjoyed your book, but I did skip all those long pas...
coffee & ink
coffee & ink rated it 14 years ago
Interesting remix of Riddle-Master, but I don't love it.
Need help?