logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

The Independence of Miss Mary Bennet - Community Reviews back

by Colleen McCullough
sort by language
Roving Book Club
Roving Book Club rated it 10 years ago
Read by Tiffany: A rollicking read, but not what I expected from a 20 years later sequel to Pride and Prejudice! Mary attacked by a highwayman, kidnapped by a weird religious cult and held captive in a cage in a cave, Lydia murdered, Lizzie and Mr Darcy unhappy .. quelle horreur!! .. and by the end ...
oh, carrots.
oh, carrots. rated it 12 years ago
Man, if you want to see a fandom wig out, just insert a bit of reality into their happily ever after narrative. This is not a one star book. It's a more than competent piece of fiction. Fiction being the key word. P&P isn't real, folks.Jane Austen books are fun because they aren't demanding. Good an...
Palito de Café
Palito de Café rated it 13 years ago
La historia no es mala. Creo que esta de más decir que es "la vida de" algún personaje de orgullo y prejuicio.No me gusto que se le tome tanta importancia a Lizzie, menos con una actitud tan cartucha como para no hablar con Darcy acerca de sus "problemas"No me gusto que le digan "Fitz" a Darcy, es t...
Breadcrumb Reads
Breadcrumb Reads rated it 14 years ago
Update as on 18 May 2011 - I decided to read the book through since I can't bare to leave a book unfinished.:-/I was forewarned by the reviews that I had read. But I thought I would give this a try anyway...mainly because the author, Colleen McCullough, is a favourite of mine. It was a disaster, thi...
Bookloving writer
Bookloving writer rated it 14 years ago
I got this book sort of by accident, but found it quite an interesting read. However, I think Jane Austen herself would have been shocked by some of the topics this book touched upon. Perhaps that shouldn't have been a concern for me, but it was.
wealhtheow
wealhtheow rated it 15 years ago
Goldjadeocean says, "takes on sexism, classism, racism, colonialism, and religious extremism latent in the original Austen" I'm in!
inconceivably
inconceivably rated it 16 years ago
Okay...you can obviously see from all the other reviews that this is not the most popular of Pride and Prejudice sequels. Darcy and Elizabeth do not spend 99% of their time having sex, and he does not cater to her hand and foot all the days of their lives.*shrugs* Sorry. Those things don't happen in...
Vilja Reads
Vilja Reads rated it 16 years ago
Overall, I found this novel enjoyable. It did, however, have such an easily quantifiable incidents of win and fail that I will attempt to list them here.Of course, you might not agree. I realize that for many what I cound as wins they would rather be quantified as fails, and vice versa.Spoilers belo...
DP9
DP9 rated it 16 years ago
Good fun. In a way, it was a bit like a fan fiction, except considerably better researched. McCullough took Austen's characters off for a bit of good old-fashioned adventure, and has presented us with what I can only describe as a ripping yarn.
Need help?