logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

The Mysterious Benedict Society - Community Reviews back

by Trenton Lee Stewart, Carson Ellis
sort by language
Reading For The Heck Of It
Reading For The Heck Of It rated it 7 years ago
I have really been enjoying the exploration of my library's middle grade fiction section. For the most part, I just grabbed books from the shelves that had interesting covers. This led me to The Mysterious Benedict Society by Trenton Lee Stewart with illustrations by Carson Ellis (I told you she'd b...
An Un-Calibrated Centrifuge
An Un-Calibrated Centrifuge rated it 8 years ago
I zipped through the beginning of the book, but the ending took a while to finish. I don't remember having trouble reading any of the books the first time around. Not sure what happened this time (I did feel like there was a lot of telling... maybe that was part of it). But I like the characters so ...
A Man With An Agenda
A Man With An Agenda rated it 8 years ago
Eeeeeh. I can see why the series has become so popular with children, but then children do like to be talked down to and like their characters broadly defined by one or two - one or two only - characteristics and have villains with vague, improbable plans that are easily foiled. In other words, 'The...
Dang Rover: Cover to Cover
Dang Rover: Cover to Cover rated it 8 years ago
It's so hard to find really good middle grade books. In an effort to write a story that is "on their level," most of them are poorly written, have overly simplistic plots, and canned, characterless characters. At last, I've found one that dares to assume our kids aren't stupid! The Mysterious ...
A Bit Bookish
A Bit Bookish rated it 9 years ago
The Mysterious Benedict Society gave me hope for future generations in the way that Matilda probably gave adults hope for my generation. The story is told Harry Potter-style, through the eyes of Reynie Muldoon - a kind-hearted and intelligent kid who actually reminded me a little bit of Harry Potter...
Fangirls Ahead!
Fangirls Ahead! rated it 10 years ago
hmm. other than the fact that I could predict the plot twists a few pages before they happened, I also felt like the characters were a tad cardboardy. I mean, is Constance ever not grumpy? exactly. but I liked it.
Bashara Likes Books
Bashara Likes Books rated it 11 years ago
Is there a word for a book that starts with great promise whose momentum just peters out about halfway through? I feel like this is a fairly common problem in the literary world and there ought to be a word! And maybe there is and I just don't know it. I was super stoked when this book was chose...
One Page at a Time
One Page at a Time rated it 11 years ago
I really don't know what I expected when I was intrigued by this book in the bookstore, but it was so much better than I expected it to be. The characters really came alive to me and the whole story was very interesting. The puzzles were interesting, and the solutions creative. I am really lookin...
Inner Sparkle Reviews
Inner Sparkle Reviews rated it 11 years ago
Reynie Muldoon, George "Sticky" Washington, Kate Wetherall, and Constance Contraire are three children on a mission. A mission to save the world from a most terrible fate. When these four ace a test designed to weed out the best of the best, the cleverest of the clever, and the most imaginative of...
Paperback Castles
Paperback Castles rated it 11 years ago
One day I found a picture of this book on Tumblr. I saw the beautiful illustrations and the mysterious title, and I knew it. I knew I had to read it. I quickly found a synopsis of its plot, praise for its author and comparisons towards Roald Dahl and the Harry Potter books. I didn't doubt it for a s...
Need help?