logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Why Shoot A Butler? - Community Reviews back

by Georgette Heyer
sort by language
Murder by Death
Murder by Death rated it 5 years ago
An accidental re-read, but an enjoyable one. As I started reading it, I remembered my frustration the first time around with the slow, purposefully vague start, but once into it, I enjoyed the banter and the mystery again - and had no recollection as to whodunnit.
Tannat
Tannat rated it 7 years ago
I was worried that I wouldn't like this book because of my disastrous encounter with Venetia, one of Heyer's regency romances, but this was pretty good. Mr. Frank Amberley, a barrister visiting his relatives in the country, comes across a man shot dead in a parked car with a woman standing alongs...
KizunaYueMichaelis
KizunaYueMichaelis rated it 9 years ago
The best GH mystery I've read so far. It was a bit Gothic is some parts, and there is plenty of humor (although there are 2 murders + 1 attempt of murder). I would love to see a BBC adaptation of this.Amberley was a bit arrogant and the little romance was a bit MEH, though.
Murder by Death
Murder by Death rated it 10 years ago
Ugh. First off, the narrator was awful. She sounded like an android reading this book, with weird pauses in the middle of the sentences and almost no inflection. Her voice is lovely, but she did a hatchet job on the narration. It did improve by the end, but too late to make me forget how painful...
Darth Pedant
Darth Pedant rated it 10 years ago
I am a sucker for Agatha Christie-esque mysteries, and Georgette Heyer pulled this one off brilliantly. It's got a know-it-all Gary Stu amateur detective, bumbling policemen who couldn't detect the noses on their faces, swell blokes and plucky dames, and a bull terrier named Bill. This book was like...
melsbookshelf
melsbookshelf rated it 12 years ago
This is only the second Heyer mystery I have read and thought I enjoyed it, I'm not sure I liked it as much as Detection Unlimited. With Why Shoot a Butler? Heyer takes a different approach by having law enforcement officials that border on incompetent and an amateur who is much more talented in the...
CharlotteBuriedinBooks
CharlotteBuriedinBooks rated it 16 years ago
I really enjoyed this book, yes it was dated and rather twee. But there were some great characters - Frank Amberley (the rudest man in London) and his Uncle Humphrey and Aunt Marion were great fun.I didn't guess who did it but I didn't really mind.The only thing that did upset me was the standard o...
What I'm reading
What I'm reading rated it 18 years ago
Interesting in a classic whodunnit type of plot. Set in the 30's in England, Heyer places her characters in a very rigid kinda plot. Frank Amberley, barrister and part time amateur detective, comes across as stiff and cold. Maybe it's because I've been totally spoiled by Sayers' graceful writing tha...
Need help?