logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Brian Selznick - Community Reviews back

sort by language
Under The Mountain
Under The Mountain rated it 13 years ago
Yep, you've guessed it - this is a modern day retelling of the famous A Christmas Carol. This short book tells of Ben's journey after the death of his girlfriend, Marley. Some interesting elements are added here - for instance Tiny Tim has now become a male gay couple and Valentine's Day has replced...
By Singing Light
By Singing Light rated it 14 years ago
When I read The Invention of Hugo Cabret, I was enchanted by the pictures but not by the words. In Wonderstruck, the written story is much stronger–helped, I think, by the fact that the text and the pictures tell two distinct stories. They are related, but I won’t say how. [Oct. 2011]
Bibliofiend's Bookbag
Bibliofiend's Bookbag rated it 14 years ago
Fantastic! Selznick is a marvel with his storytelling and his illustrations - not to mention how they weave two stories together that are poignant. I highly recommend it.
Kaethe
Kaethe rated it 14 years ago
I love the way Selznick told two different stories, and brought them together. It's enchanting how perfectly the pieces fit. Library copy.
nessochist
nessochist rated it 14 years ago
Gah. So pretty.
julieharrison
julieharrison rated it 14 years ago
Pretty genius, how the written story from the 1970s corresponds with the drawn story from the 1920s. And the way it ties together is so amazing and satisfying. I subtracted one star because for some reason I didn't feel connected to Ben, despite many reasons I should. Definitely a great book, though...
Bright and Shiny Shiny
Bright and Shiny Shiny rated it 14 years ago
So beautiful and when the two stories finally become one it's breathtaking.
Bright and Shiny Shiny
Bright and Shiny Shiny rated it 14 years ago
So beautiful and when the two stories finally become one it's breathtaking.
pedestrienne
pedestrienne rated it 14 years ago
I was fortunate to get my hands on an ARC of this at ALA. Although I'm not a fan of the size of Selznick's books - the book size makes the gutters really deep, which swallows up some of the art, and that will never make sense to me except as a gambit to help kids transition from picture books to the...
Peace, Love & Books
Peace, Love & Books rated it 14 years ago
Brilliant!
Need help?