Fraternal twins, Annabelle and Willie, whose widowed father is about to remarry, send for a mail-order bride to prevent him marrying a woman they hate. Annabelle and Willie are inseparable since the loss of their mother in a tornado. Their father is convinced he must marry Harriet, who he thinks will help Willie overcome the trauma and speak again. Annabelle and Willie instinctively dislike her, and set out to find their father a different wife. Grace Haggerty is tired of being the designated town spinster. Everyone in the county knows she can never have children, and big farms are a way of life. Her sister encourages her to marry an older man who doesn’t want children, but she still dreams of love and a family of her own. Can Grace overcome her embarrassment that Will does not want her for a wife? Can Will see that bringing someone the whole family can love into his home is the only way to help is son?