logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

September Girls - Community Reviews back

by Bennett Madison
sort by language
Wrenegade
Wrenegade rated it 11 years ago
This was, overall, a meh read for me. I really disliked the first 50 pages or so, and then it got better, and then it had an anticlimactic ending. It didn't send me into a feminist rage, but I can't really recommend it either. Sam seems like an okay guy. He tries to understand his mother leaving,...
Bright and Shiny Shiny
Bright and Shiny Shiny rated it 11 years ago
Review to come but I loved it!!
By Singing Light
By Singing Light rated it 11 years ago
This post is perhaps a little different from my usual reviews. That’s because it’s essentially a comment for the SLJ’s Printz Blog which, for some reason, I was having trouble articulating over there. Also, since that blog has all the spoilers, this post will too. Don’t keep reading if you don’t wan...
Wyvernfriend Reads
Wyvernfriend Reads rated it 11 years ago
*Braces for impact*I liked this one, I didn't expect to having read a multitude of reviews that panned it, but I actually liked this one. I will also say that it wasn't perfect but I found it a good read.It would probably be best described as closer to magic realism than true fantasy, the fantasy i...
sarahonthecoast
sarahonthecoast rated it 11 years ago
This book was abysmal. Dreadful. I found absolutely no redeeming qualities within its pages.
Syahira's Literary Obsession
Syahira's Literary Obsession rated it 11 years ago
This book have been on the spotlight on Nathan Bransford’s blog which was used to show how pathological bullish is the reviewers of Goodreads can be on a book and the link was shared on the NaNoWriMo facebook and apparently I receive this reply when I said about there’s always two side of the story ...
target acquired
target acquired rated it 11 years ago
I'm excited to read this! although the subject matter looks only slightly interesting to me, all of the 1-star reviews of this book are so hilarious that I am sold. but not because they are making the book look bad, not at all. all that disgust over the casual sexism and the characters' relentless t...
Jill
Jill rated it 12 years ago
Sexist? Feminist? Blah, who cares? September Girls has inspired some extreme opinions for a book that that is the literary equivalent of a sigh. I definitely don’t consider it sexist as so many reviewers have. The characters use coarse and objective words to describe women, but it shows how this typ...
Howdy YAL!
Howdy YAL! rated it 12 years ago
To see full review click here.I've mentioned it before, but I hated high school. For many reasons. Probably my worst memory in high school involved being sexually harassed by a group of dipshits who only thought with their dick and didn't know the meaning of fuck off. This book reminds me of thos...
dei reads
dei reads rated it 12 years ago
This is a fucked-up fairy tale wherein everything comes down to one's own interpretation for one to be able to rate it with stars -- or no stars at all, like what the majority of raging readers did.I don't believe a character with a dick personality already equates to an awful book. Besides, it was ...
Need help?