logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

September Girls - Community Reviews back

by Bennett Madison
sort by language
Ashleigh Paige
Ashleigh Paige rated it 11 years ago
Well, I guess I fall in the camp that says this critiques sexism and women's roles in a way. It's decent commentary, but that doesn't excuse the God awful, cringeworthy dialogue, poor pacing/plotting (I skipped about 60 pages with no detriment to my reading experience), characterization issues, and ...
Erin Bowman
Erin Bowman rated it 11 years ago
Bennett Madison's SEPTEMBER GIRLS seems to be a book that people either love or hate. Having read, I can see why there is such a strong divide--it's not an easy read, and Madison puts the reader deep into the mind of his teen protagonist--but I'm in camp Love. This book floored me. Truly. It is a st...
SakuraMorimoto
SakuraMorimoto rated it 12 years ago
well i dont know what to say about this book. i had no idea it would be paranormal fiction. when i started reading it i thought that it was just an indie book with a coming of age theme but no.at some point people started falling in love and act weird until BOOM! mermaids appear. i was like wtf!!!i ...
SakuraMorimoto
SakuraMorimoto rated it 12 years ago
well i dont know what to say about this book. i had no idea it would be paranormal fiction. when i started reading it i thought that it was just an indie book with a coming of age theme but no.at some point people started falling in love and act weird until BOOM! mermaids appear. i was like wtf!!!i ...
Inspiring Insomnia
Inspiring Insomnia rated it 12 years ago
This was just not for me. The story was far-fetched, but it still managed to be uninteresting. I didn't mind the language in the book, which I know was turn-off for many readers, because it's probably the most believable part of the story.
Emily May (The Book Geek)
Emily May (The Book Geek) rated it 12 years ago
Cast your pitchforks aside, I'm going to try and explain. Explain why this book which is lauded by critics but generally hated by goodreads (and many of my friends on the site), criticised as being misogynistic and disgusting and appalling and many other colourfully negative words... was a completel...
sabthebookeater
sabthebookeater rated it 12 years ago
This review and more on Sab The Book EaterDon’t let the pretty cover fool you – this book is far from fluffy and sweet. September Girls has a lot of cussing and sex… or talk of sex. I can’t say there was a lot of sex because Sam, the main character, barely got some and he complained about it a lot. ...
A Lot Like Dreaming
A Lot Like Dreaming rated it 12 years ago
First of all, I would like to thank the Publisher, HarperTeen for giving me an ARC of this book to review. Thank you so much! Really appreciate it! All right, now for my review.(My Opinion)I can understand why some people won't enjoy this because there are many times where Sam randomly talks about ...
The Aussie Zombie
The Aussie Zombie rated it 12 years ago
The first thing that attracted me to September Girls was the cover. Despite the fact that coupled with the synopsis it strongly hinted at a mermaid story, which I have pretty mixed feelings about, it also sounded kinda mysterious too, which was an added drawcard.The very first thing that struck me ...
Gypsy Reviews
Gypsy Reviews rated it 12 years ago
Originally posted at Gypsy ReviewsI received an eARC from HarperTeen via Edelweiss. Thank you!Congratulations September Girls, you have gotten my first 1 star rating ever. I don’t give these out to any old book, I give these even more rarely than I give 5 star reviews. Just fantastic with your portr...
Need help?