Betty “Nana” Hart is frustrated with her grandson Hunter. He is clearly the town hunk, a successful businessman and an all-around great guy. The problem is he has yet to give her a great-grandchild. Her friend Agnes is always bragging about being a great-grandmother and Betty wants that too. When she hears that Hunter’s lost love, Elliott (Ellie) Starks is back in town, she decides to play cupid and get the two together. After all great-grandchildren don’t make themselves!

Ellie Starks has moved back home and taken the position of Events Coordinator for the town. She decides to throw a Valentine’s Day Dance to help benefit the Animal Shelter. And when Nana Hart walks into her office and offers up a donation of three-hundred decadent cupcakes baked by her grandson Hunter, Ellie can’t refuse. Even though she had been in town four months and had yet to hear from her High School Sweetheart, he was still the man she loved after all the years spent apart.

Hunter Hart, owner and pastry chef at Cupid’s Cakes knew his Nana was up to something, he just couldn’t figure out what. Until the night he walked into the Animal Shelter and came face to face with Ellie. Ellie had been the only woman he had ever loved. He had been hurt when the letters he had written her came back unopened, but he was determined to show her just how much he still wanted her in his life. Now if only he can find a way to get into that Valentine’s Day Dance.