logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code
back to top
Search tags: Rebecca-West
Load new posts () and activity
Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
review 2016-12-28 15:43
Die Rückkehr des Soldaten
Die Rückkehr: Roman - Rebecca West,Britta Mümmler

Während des 1. Weltkriegs halten Jenny und Kitty Baldry das Landgut der Familie auf Vordermann. Alles soll perfekt sein, wenn Kittys Ehemann Chris, der Herr des Hauses, von der Front aus Frankreich zurückkommt. Doch dann erhalten sie die Nachricht, dass der geliebte Ehemann und Cousin einen Granatenschock erlitten hat, und sich an nichts aus der jetzigen Zeit erinnern kann.

Als vordergründiges Thema werden der 1. Weltkrieg sowie der „Granatenschock“ an sich angepriesen. Meinem Empfinden nach sind diese beiden Aspekte aber sehr in den Hintergrund gerutscht und es ist ein kleines Gesellschaftsdrama geblieben, das die feinere Gesellschaft in ihre Schranken weist.

Chris leidet unter einem Granatenschock. Dabei sind die Soldaten äußerlich unversehrt, haben aber mit psychischen Symptomen zu kämpfen, die zu dieser Zeit nicht immer anerkannt wurden. In Chris’ Fall kann er sich an sein gegenwärtiges Leben nicht erinnern und hängt einer Liebe aus der Vergangenheit nach. Die Geliebte, die er vor 15 Jahren kennengelernt hat, ist mit von der häuslichen Partie und so ergibt sich eine merkwürdige Vierecksbeziehung, die der übergreifende Rahmen ist.

Als Protagonistin habe ich seine Cousine Jenny empfunden. Sie ist bei Chris’ Ehefrau Kitty geblieben und die beiden Frauen haben für Ordnung im herrschaftlichen Anwesen gesorgt. Nun nimmt sie die Rolle der Vermittlerin ein und setzt alles daran, Chris wieder gesund zu bekommen. Dabei zögern die Frauen nicht einmal, die einstige Geliebte ins Haus zu holen.

Kitty, Lady des Hauses und Chris’ Ehefrau, kommt meiner Meinung nach zu unrecht sehr schlecht in der Geschichte weg. Sie wird als oberflächlicher Dekorgegenstand beschrieben, der sich gegen die alte Liebe ihres Ehemanns stellt. Ich hoffe, hier sieht man anhand meiner Wortwahl schon, wie unfair ich diese Darstellung empfinde, denn immerhin hat Chris auch Kitty geheiratet und sie kann nichts dafür, dass er sie sich als Ehefrau genommen hat.

Der Schreibstil ist trotz der fast 100 Jahre angenehm zu lesen und die Beschreibungen an sich sind der Autorin gut gelungen. Auch mit den Charakteren konnte ich mitfühlen und sie wurden für ein doch recht knappes Werk exzellent abgebildet.

Dieses Buch hat bestimmt literarischen Wert. Vor allem wenn man bedenkt, dass es das einzige zeitgenössische Werk über den 1. Weltkrieg ist, das von einer Frau geschrieben wurde. Trotzdem muss ich sagen, dass es mir insgesamt nicht besonders gefallen hat, weil es mir einfach zu wenig Bezug zum Kriegsgeschehen und zur damaligen Gesellschaft herstellt.

Klassikerfreunde sollten sich wohl unbedingt ein eigenes Bild von Rebecca Wests „Die Rückkehr“ machen, obwohl ich nicht das Gefühl habe, dass mir ohne dieses Buch viel entgangen wäre. 

 
Source: zeit-fuer-neue-genres.blogspot.co.at
Like Reblog Comment
review 2016-08-22 00:00
The Return of the Soldier
The Return of the Soldier - Rebecca West Please note that I gave this book 4.5 stars, but rounded it up to 5 stars on Goodreads.

I read this story for The Dead Writers Society, 2016 Genre Fiction August 2016 book.

This story is (expletive) up. Seriously. You have a husband and wife separated by World War I. The husband's cousin is living with the wife and seems to sit around with constantly wet eyes thinking about "their Chris". And then the wife (Kitty) finds out that her husband who she loves is wounded with amnesia/shell shock and does not recall her or their life together. Instead he remembers a younger love and goes around telling people he will just die if he can't see/be with her. This story is (expletive) up.

So I disliked the character of Jenny (cousin to Chris) a lot. She had ever changing loyalties about what needed to be done about Chris. And depending on the way that the clouds were moving in the sky shifted her loyalties to her cousin, his wife, or his cousin's old love. Can you tell I did not care for her? Cause I did not.

I felt the most for Kitty who though she seems hard hearted, you realize she has suffered losses as well. She wants her husband to come back to her so they can resume their lives together again. This latest issue has her barely holding it together, and she at times gets to she Jenny for the grasping piece of crap she is (yep, still hate Jenny).

Chris you don't get a sense of much at all besides his selfishness. I get that he had shell shock and amnesia. But after being told by the 20th person around that things had changed, all he wanted to do was sit around and be around his old love Margaret. Of course that wasn't going to be able to be his future forever. The fact that Margaret and Jenny even entertained the notion drove me up the wall.

The writing was very good, but told from Jenny's point of view I think at times you realize that her words are at odds with what is going on. The flow was great too because you just keep reading and reading and wondering what in the heck is the ending going to reveal.

I thought the setting of the house from a happy shining place to a place that became cold and indifferent was sad. I can see how the war would change Chris from the younger man who had the whole world in front of him, to one who experienced a terrible war and also other losses in his life.

The ending set things up as the most bitter ending to a book I can remember in a time. I think in that instance Jenny realized what would happen if her and Kitty got "their Chris" back. So one wonders, what would have been best for him and them?
Like Reblog Comment
review 2016-01-30 00:05
The Return of the Soldier - Verlyn Klinkenborg,Rebecca West,Norman Price

Lost chances and missed opportunities, resignation, change, war, suppression and oppression are among the themes surrounding West’s novel. For such a short novel, it is heavy. The heaviness is pervasive and there is no sense of reprieve for any of the characters. The novel’s narrator does begin her story almost with an apology…things aren’t as they seem…the people you’ll meet will not be in their best form. What unfolds is a highly depressing tale for our protagonist Chris. Though he once found happiness in his youth, he let it fall away in a sudden moment of angry frustration. The life he currently has with his wife is likewise frustrating…a wife of cold, statuesque beauty who has turned his home into a modern palace. When reading, one might readily notice elements that Daphne du Maurier would later develop in her novel Rebecca

 

The effects of war have left Chris in shell shocked repressed state. But even in this state, he’s unhappy and unsatisfied. Though he is given the opportunity to rekindle his friendship with his lost first love, Margaret, there is still an underlying unhappiness and unrest. Though initially Margaret does seem to be a voice of reason, this feeling is soon lost when she’s left to make fanciful, mystical notions about the children they both lost in the new relationships they had forged.

 

Once Chris “awakens” from his repressed fog, he is left with only one course to take—a course that is seemingly no better than any of the others with which he has faced. West’s novel is about loneliness and aloneness met in various states.

Like Reblog Comment
review 2015-10-18 00:00
The Return Of The Soldier
The Return Of The Soldier - Rebecca West,Sadie Jones review to come
Like Reblog Comment
review 2015-03-14 20:39
The Return Of The Soldier - Rebecca West,Sadie Jones

The Return of the Soldier is an interesting read for several reasons, not least because it is a female authored book about the very male topic of the shell shock that often resulted from World War One. It's stylistic, and overly simplistic in places, and yet despite this it is extremely effective in showing the difficulties in coming to terms with the personal effects of the war.

 

At the beginning of the novella, I had little sympathy for any of the female characters involved. They seemed to be deceitful and dishonest with each other, and their idea of what Chris was before the war seemed far more important to them than the relationships they should have built between each other. The narrative voice at the start seems to give little away, but over the course of the book, grey areas creep in, and the reasonings behind the characters acting in the way they do become clear.

 

Ultimately, they have to decide between letting the man that they care for so much be happy at their expense, and "curing" him so that he can resume his former duties, both at home and presumably in the war effort.

More posts
Your Dashboard view:
Need help?