logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code
Discussion: 16 Tasks of the Festive Season: The Rules -- and Questions About the Rules
posts: 9 views: 1929 last post: 4 years ago
back to group back to club
Reply to post #92 (show post):

The setting is a small seaside town, so my question about it being near the sea was kind of moot, actually... O.o
Reply to post #94 (show post):

Regency novels set in a small seaside town? Oh, sure ... hits all the (various) marks! :D
Reply to post #95 (show post):

I thought so, but was drawing a blank on whether they fit or not. Ugh, it's been a long week...

But yay! Thanks!
FYI, all: I asked MbD for a judgement call on whether a book set in the Southern Hemisphere and (in part) on Summer Solstice can count for a holiday joker to be used for Square 9, Winter Solstice -- because as we're saying in the description of the square, Summer Solstice in the Southern Hemisphere occurs on the same day as Winter Solstice in the Northern Hemisphere. My feeling was it should count, but since it's a book I'm currently listening to, I didn't want to make the decision myself. MbD agreed, so:

Any book set in part on Summer Solstice and set in the Southern Hemisphere can be used as a holiday joker for Square 9, Winter Solstice.
Couple of quick questions:

For the Festivus task in which you perform the airing of the grievances, does it have to be five books? What if I have less than that?

For the St. Martin's Day book task in which you read a book set before the age of electricity. That mean books set before the turn of the 20th century, yes?
Reply to post #98 (show post):

If there were less than 5 books you disliked this year, then it's less than 5 books!

Will get back to you separately on your other question; I'd just like to make sure MbD and I have the same understanding on where exactly to draw the line here.
Reply to post #99 (show post):

Thanks, Themis!
OK, here's the deal on "the Age of Electricity": There are quite a few inventions that can legitimately be considered to have brought about the turning of a new leaf -- many, though not all of them occurring towards the end of the 19th century.

Two particularly significant developments were Edison's inventions and the (simultaneous) switch from gas light to electrical street lamps in major cities across Europe and the U.S. in the late 1870s and 1880s; both of these signalled huge leaps in making electricity widely available in daily use.

So this is where we'd therefore set the line: Anything before the late 1870s and 1880s counts as "before the Age of Electricity."
Reply to post #101 (show post):

Thanks for the clarification!
Need help?