Amy has a new identity as JJ. For the past two years, she has enjoyed her new life tucked away in Hillside, a small town, hiding from Peter Berollio, ex-consigliore to alleged mob boss Joseph Mandrolatti. Her perception continues to deepen. When the Mayor’s granddaughter, Lori, goes missing JJ’s anonymous tip leads to her whereabouts. News of this event is printed in the local newspaper. As requests for help begin to trickle in, Glenn Carlson local journalist, thinks the real story is uncovering the identity of the anonymous caller putting JJ’s life in jeopardy. Meantime, JJ happens upon her landlady’s family pictures dating to the 1950’s which reveal a surprising connection.