logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Ash - Community Reviews back

by Malinda Lo
sort by language
Bookaholic-ness~
Bookaholic-ness~ rated it 12 years ago
I have this thing for retellings. Like, it's the same but only different. It's unique and original at the same time as it was adapted. I've been meaning to read this for a long time, and i think the only reason I brought it up to the top of my TBR list is because Malinda Lo is coming in for an autho...
Alexis Hall
Alexis Hall rated it 12 years ago
This is a lesbian Cinderella re-telling. 'Nough said, right?Actually, it's probably not what you think. It's a strangely cold and bleak book in many ways. Ash spends pretty much the entire thing lost in her grief at the death of her father, deeply depressed and basically suicidal. Her Fairy Godmoth...
The Layaway Dragon
The Layaway Dragon rated it 12 years ago
I loved the idea of a lesbian Cinderella retelling. I thought she'd end up or at least fall in love with a princess instead of prince. I was wrong but that wasn't a problem. The huntress, Kasia, was fine and it makes more sense than a princess. Ash could actually run into and hang out with her. Whi...
The Layaway Dragon
The Layaway Dragon rated it 12 years ago
I loved the idea of a lesbian Cinderella retelling. I thought she'd end up or at least fall in love with a princess instead of prince. I was wrong but that wasn't a problem. The huntress, Kasia, was fine and it makes more sense than a princess. Ash could actually run into and hang out with her. Whi...
The Reading Shelf
The Reading Shelf rated it 12 years ago
3.5 stars
FrkHyms
FrkHyms rated it 12 years ago
It was everything I wanted it to be and a little more.
Kate Bond
Kate Bond rated it 12 years ago
Gay YA. I bought this and read it for the first time in Paris three years ago. I re-read it in hopes that I'd like it this time, but the writing is still flat and dull. Making Cinderella a lesbian was a brilliant move, though.
are you going to finish that?
are you going to finish that? rated it 12 years ago
3.5. I don't read many retellings but this one was very well done in terms of simultaneously staying in touch with the source material and telling a new story. I didn't really mind the abrupt ending, which I thought was in keeping with the fairy tale convention as well, but I think the language was ...
Thief of Camorr
Thief of Camorr rated it 13 years ago
Well written YA with quite a different plot to anything else I've read recently. Deals with same-sex relationships in a very, very good way - something that should be more prevalent in YA in general.
Nemo @ The Moonlight Library
Nemo @ The Moonlight Library rated it 13 years ago
See this review and more on The Moonlight Library!When Ash’s mother, full of fairy tales and knowledge of the old ways, dies, her father remarries a woman who brings two horrendous daughters to the household. Well, Ash is a Cinderella retelling, so that bit should be obvious. But this is a Cinderell...
Need help?