logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Ash - Community Reviews back

by Malinda Lo
sort by language
Something clever I'll change later
Something clever I'll change later rated it 13 years ago
As seen on Stumptown Books.I picked this book up because I planned on reading Huntress. This book was written first, so I thought, "Sure, I'll give it a try, even if this is not my normal bag."The first thing to note is that this is a fairy tale retelling. Ask yourself: do you like fairy tale retell...
Rrain Reads
Rrain Reads rated it 13 years ago
I've been meaning to read this book for ages and I have no idea what took me this long. Maybe because I love the idea of queer retellings of fairy tales and myth, but am so often disappointed with the result. I definitely was not disappointed with this one. There are some things that I would have li...
MargaretBolingMullin
MargaretBolingMullin rated it 13 years ago
6/18/12 ** Saw HUNTRESS by Lo recommended twice by people who follow Tamora Pierce, so figured I'd enjoy that; this is in the same world and was written prior to HUNTRESS, so I'm starting with this. 6/22/12 ** Started yesterday and am half way through. Interesting twist on Cinderella so far.
Nina @ Death Books and Tea
Nina @ Death Books and Tea rated it 13 years ago
Review: Aisling, or Ash, is ten when her mother dies. Her father soon follows, but not before he marries Lady Isobel. With him dead, Isobel reduce sash to a slave. One day, she ventures into the forest, and meets Fairy Sidhean. They exchange stories, and see each other a few times. On her other day...
An Un-Calibrated Centrifuge
An Un-Calibrated Centrifuge rated it 13 years ago
I enjoyed Ash as much as I think is possible for me. This is not my usual fare. I don’t really read fantasy. And if I do, I tend towards sci-fi fantasy/adventure stories than romances. That said, Ash wasn’t bad. It might be cliche. I don’t know. I have nothing to compare it to. (I’m guessing it’s no...
So Many Books, So Little Time
So Many Books, So Little Time rated it 13 years ago
Huh. I liked the fairy tale feel of this book, as well as the stories within the stories. I thought that Clara was a nice touch as someone who is confused by her mother and her sister's mean treatment of the undeserving Ash. Her conflict was rather interesting to me. I also thought it was cool that ...
Kaethe
Kaethe rated it 13 years ago
Lo incorporates two aspects into this retelling of Cinderella that I really loved: 1) she really enters into the life of a servant 2) she tells a lot of fairy tales. The first element grounds the story for a modern reader, reminds us of just how arduous it would be to be the maid-of-all-work in a ho...
Second Bookses
Second Bookses rated it 13 years ago
Ash is a retelling of the Cinderella myth as an actual fairy tale, involving fairies, fairy lore, witches, a curse, and yes, queer acceptance.Ash is Aisling, orphaned after her mother's death and her father's subsequent remarriage to a woman with two daughters and a house in the city. Aisling's moth...
Melody Murray's Books
Melody Murray's Books rated it 13 years ago
Ash tastes like Tam Lin, but it does not satisfy in the same way. I do applaud the fairy tales aimed at the GLBT teen, as this is, but ultimately it didn't entirely work for me. The heroine is likable enough, but the story is muddy- the magic is muddy, even. The relationships are turbid, the prose, ...
I Live in Many Worlds
I Live in Many Worlds rated it 13 years ago
Well, this book was a pleasant surprise. I wasn't expecting to like this book as much as I did. When I first heard about this book, there was nothing but negative reviews on it. I didn't understand what all the hate was about so, me being the sick and twisted little girl that I am, I wanted nothing ...
Need help?