logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code
back to top
Search tags: China-adoption
Load new posts () and activity
Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
review 2014-03-31 06:33
Made In China by Vanita Oelschlager
Made in China: A Story of Adoption - Vanita Oelschlager,Kristin Blackwood

**Thank you VanitaBooks and Netgalley for providing this in exchange for a honest review**

I have mixed feelings about this title. There were a few things that really bothered me. The story starts with two sisters cleaning together. The younger sister, who was adopted out of China, asks her sister to read the words stamped on the broom. The Words are "Made in China". The older sister proceeds to taunt the younger one. She says things that make it seem the younger sister isn't worth more then the other objects through the house that were also Made in China. Of course, this upsets the little girl. She runs to her father to find out if this is true. Instead of saying "Your sister is being a snotty Brat" (then dealing with the older sisters atrocious behavior) he says "Yes you were made in China, but it was to bring us joy" (paraphrasing there). To me, it sounds like he just confirmed what the older sister was saying. To tell her "you were made to bring us joy" sounds like "You were made for our entertainment". The father does say a few redeeming things about how much he loves her, but he continued to use the phrase Made in China when referring to her. It just rubbed me the wrong way. Another thing that bothered me is the older sister is never reprimanded for tearing down her little sister. I understand this is a book for a younger audience. However, I think the age group this is meant for is when you need to start making things clear to children. It's when they start learning what is acceptable behavior and what isn't. I don't think it's ok that this little girl was made to feel awful by someone who is meant to love and protect her. And the story made it seem like it was ok.

Once again, Kristin Blackwood illustrations are beautiful. She is a truly talented illustrator.

Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
review 2014-01-30 22:12
This book is going right on my Favorites shelf
The Jade Rabbit - Mark Matthews

Her husband Randall calls her Sweet J; the kids at the Shelter call her Ms. Janice.  Zhu is the name she was given at the Chinese orphanage where she lived after being given up by her China-Mama, before she was adopted by her American parents. Number 1242 is the number she will be wearing as she runs her next marathon.

 

All these things have shaped her: her abandonment by her mother who was trying for  a boy; her loving adoptive parents; her training for runs;  her happy marriage; and her work as the Director at a center for troubled children.

 

I don't know much about most of these things, but Mark Matthews' book made me feel like an expert.

 

Ms. Janice is counseling a troubled teen, Hailey, who is at the shelter because she isn't safe with her mother and she isn't safe with her father.  Hailey is pregnant, and Janice shares that she is adopted.

 

"'So I guess your mother didn't want you?' Hailey asked, clearly amazed at my story.

 

'Well, my biological mother, or my China-Mama,  as I called her didn't really have a choice because of how it is there.  She was actually making a big risk just to get me to the orphanage . . . So really she loved me more than most.  Some infant girls are actually killed at birth.  Had China-Mama  not loved me, I wouldn't be here.  She knows I'm okay though,' I said,  and turned to smile into Hailey's eyes.  'She feels it.'

 

In reality, Janice has abandonment issues and wages a constant struggle to overcome them.  Her parents are excellent.  Her Mom is a marathoner, and Janice started training with her at an early age.  Her mother is adept at making sure Janice knows she is loved all the years of her childhood, not only by herself and her father, but also by the birth mother who had given her up.

 

"'In a perfect world, China-Mama could have raised you.  I don't kid myself about this,' is what my mom always told me, 'but we are perfect for each other so [we] can be grateful for that.'"  

 

Janice is currently focused on two girls in particular, Hailey and Sharleen, both of whom have disappeared.  Janice suspects they are sleeping in the basement at the shelter, and is in a quandary as to how to deal with it.  There are legalities and ethics involved, but sometimes doing the thing that is right falls outside the boundaries.  Also Janice's own unresolved childhood issues are in play; she wants to ensure she remains the protector and not a perpetrator.  Yet these same issues have honed her and made her stronger.  These are the things that enable her to pass on the hope and the skills to enable the children at the shelter to become strong too.

 

Her daily runs are where Janice grinds through many of her problems.  Her thoughts as she runs are fascinating.  She thinks about work problems and possible resolutions; she replays memories, with her parents, with her husband; she calculates minutes and seconds as she trains; she relates the mental and physical highs and lows associated with the effort.  Almost, she made me want to think about taking up running myself.  Not because she made it sound easy, but because she made it sound so rewarding.

 

And Mark Matthews!  He must have some admirable women in his life.  Because when he writes his female characters and makes them talk about or think about or feel women's topics such as motherhood and nurturing, he made me believe that women had felt them, and spoken them, and thought them.

 

There were a very few issues with the book that I hope will be addressed in subsequent editions: for instance, once he spelled wondered when he meant wandered, more than once he used besides when it should have been beside, and quite often he  used adjectives when he should have turned them into adverbs (quickly rather than quick, slowly rather than slow).  But those little tiny things don't really matter given the greatness of the book.

 

An  angry parent came to the shelter to confront Janice, and I felt the danger.  The children revolve in and out the doors of the shelter, and I felt the hopelessness and despair.  But there is also kindness and compassion, and sometimes there is a success story.  And there is the marathon -- the preparation and the training and the actual day, and I never thought the minutia of all that could be so entertaining, but it was.

 

There's conflict resolution, character development and growth, compunction to care about what happens to the characters, and a very satisfying ending.  I can't think of anything else that needs to be added.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Like Reblog Comment
review 2013-02-26 00:00
Made in China: A Story of Adoption
Made in China: A Story of Adoption - Vanita Oelschlager,Kristin Blackwood I got this from Netgalley for a honest reviewI thought this book was immensely cute! it starts off with a big sister being particularly mean to he younger adopted sister. When the younger sister is playing with the older one she sees words written on her broom she asks her sister what it says, the older sister then replied "made in china just like you, like my shirt and my favorite plaid skirt." That of course made the younger think she was made in a factory like a doll with black hair. the story continues with the younger sister running to her dad for comfort; he then tells her about her adoption. i loved the way this book was written, the pictures gorgeous and the way the father explained her adoption was so beautiful and heartwarming that i have read it a couple times since finishing it! i beautiful book that i recommend to everybody, that is perfect for families with adopted children!
Like Reblog Comment
review 2013-02-20 00:00
Made in China: A Story of Adoption by Vanita Oelschlager
Made in China: A Story of Adoption - Vanita Oelschlager,Kristin Blackwood

an absolutely beautiful story of adoption. a fantastic book to share with an adopted child, focusing on no matter where you were "made" mum & dad love you very much & always will.
lovely illustrations to go along with the story.
an all round beautiful book.

** thanks to NetGalley & the publishers for this copy!

More posts
Your Dashboard view:
Need help?