logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

Winter's Tale - Community Reviews back

by Mark Helprin
sort by language
Mark Books
Mark Books rated it 11 years ago
Winter's Tale (my full review here) is a story of love, larceny and flying horses during New York's Belle Epoque (Just after the turn of the 20th century). It is a tale of criminal gangs, indigenous marsh-dwelling tribes, rainbow bridges and immortal architects. It is a story of love, beauty and jus...
mayhap
mayhap rated it 12 years ago
This book is mostly weird, occasionally wonderful, and about as suited for adapting into a movie as a fever dream. I literally do not see how this will work at all.
narfna
narfna rated it 12 years ago
Ugh, you guys. I was so bitterly disappointed by this book. Honestly, I’d never even heard of it until it was featured in an episode of Fringe a couple of years ago, and because Fringe is the shit, I decided to check it out. It sounded like something that had been written just for me, and indeed, ...
The Deckled Edge
The Deckled Edge rated it 12 years ago
I quite enjoyed this one, though I have to admit I was surprised at how fantastical it was for a regular fiction book. I mean, it's got flying horses and people skipping through time. Once you accept that, it's a very good book, very heavy on romanticism, idealism, and spiritualism. Plot is also ...
Romance and other things
Romance and other things rated it 12 years ago
That is why in good faith I cannot give this book less than four stars - the writing is better than so many books that I have read. I am also not sure whether this book can be called epical romance - I would call it fantasy epic about New York. I have to admit that I also enjoyed first part more tha...
NinthWanderer
NinthWanderer rated it 12 years ago
This really is gorgeous, but I can't seem to read anything right now that requires any degree of thought beyond, "Fire bad. Tree pretty." I definitely will pick this back up, perhaps once we get our first snow of the year. This really is a book that needs to be read curled up in a blanket on a wintr...
Tellulah Darling
Tellulah Darling rated it 13 years ago
As lush, magical and compelling as the city which it revolves around.
Novel Tease
Novel Tease rated it 14 years ago
A beautifully written book that goes nowhere.I finally gave up on this at the halfway point. I never quit on a book, and I'm afraid I have to blame GoodReads for giving up on this one - since I found GR I have more books than I can handle on my list!The story centres on a number of characters in Ne...
SJane
SJane rated it 14 years ago
It is with disappointment that I abandon this book, but it had a bit too much flounce. I wonder if we intuit our inappropriateness for certain books from the first pages, which in this book, for example, include a horse that can’t live without Manhattan. That was a fat clue. It turns out this horse ...
kennethjmcginnis
kennethjmcginnis rated it 14 years ago
I really can't wait to finish A Soldier of the Great War and move onto the next book.I can't imagine spending ~20 more tortuous hours reading another Helprin book with a million adjectives describing aesthetics, love and beauty...Until someone convinces me otherwise, I'm abandoning this book.
Need help?