logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

The Subtle Knife - Community Reviews back

by Philip Pullman
sort by language
Bills Books
Bills Books rated it 15 years ago
I flew through this book even though in one critical way it disappointed me greatly; Lyra didn't seem as confident in herself nor as bold in this chapter of the trilogy."The Subtle Knife" takes place on three worlds; the first is the same as that which dominated the first book. The second is the Ea...
Bills Books
Bills Books rated it 15 years ago
I flew through this book even though in one critical way it disappointed me greatly; Lyra didn't seem as confident in herself nor as bold in this chapter of the trilogy."The Subtle Knife" takes place on three worlds; the first is the same as that which dominated the first book. The second is the Ea...
TsalagiWriter
TsalagiWriter rated it 16 years ago
This is the second book in the His Dark Materials called The Subtle Knife. This book starts off with a boy named Will Parry, who is also 12 years old. Will takes care of his Mother and has ever since his Father disappeared when he was only a baby. Will loves his Mother very much and will do anything...
Qwallath
Qwallath rated it 16 years ago
Some brief thoughts; I shall collect my thoughts on the trilogy as a whole in my review of The Amber Spyglass.On the whole I found The Subtle Knife a pleasant, if somewhat chaotic continuation of the lines set out in Northern Lights. Pullman's concepts in this trilogy require a greater web of plot t...
guiltlessreader
guiltlessreader rated it 16 years ago
Definitely the best book in the trilogy.
Flying Kick-a-pow!
Flying Kick-a-pow! rated it 17 years ago
I. Hate. Will. He sucks. Why does he have to come along, and then suddenly Lyra -- who was so awesome in the first book -- becomes all pathetic and damsel-in-distress, like "oooh Will I'm gonna go fall off a cliff now!! save meeee". grrrrr it's annoying.
The Starry-Eyed Revue
The Starry-Eyed Revue rated it 17 years ago
Reviewing as a series since it's been awhile since my last read.These books are awesome, full of old ideas and new ideas and parallel universes/dimensions and talking bears. They start off slow and build to a really great story. The writing is powerful but not overwrought with details and can comp...
Melody Murray's Books
Melody Murray's Books rated it 17 years ago
Second time is not the charm, I guess. I like the story, but not as much. I like the writing, but I find myself impatient for it to be over. I hate when this happens.
Titles are so hard to come up with...
Even better than The Golden Compass, if only because the plot expands to encompass many worlds...I couldn't put it down, despite the fact that I have tons of homework to do.
Vilja Reads
Vilja Reads rated it 17 years ago
Note: This is not a review so much as some of my thoughts on the book that assumes you know the series already. Spoilers ahoy.I just KNEW there'd be deamon erotica in this series eventually. Hot monkey on snake action, people. This is the real reason the mothers of America should be worried.It's int...
Need help?