logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code

The Subtle Knife - Community Reviews back

by Philip Pullman
sort by language
Manny Rayner's book reviews
Manny Rayner's book reviews rated it 17 years ago
Well, on the whole I liked this series, but it does have some godawful terrible moments. Like, for example, the sequence where the Subtle Knife is reforged. I mean, here you are, you've got this unbelievably complex device which is capable of operating on subatomic strings in order to open up paths ...
wealhtheow
wealhtheow rated it 18 years ago
I liked most of this book better than the first one, mostly because it focuses on a new character, Will, who I like much better than Lyra. Lyra and Will dash between worlds trying to collect allies and information about Dust. As before, the writing style is uneven--very believable and engaging whe...
melissawritergrrlreads
melissawritergrrlreads rated it 18 years ago
This one took a little longer to get into than the first one, but I think that was only because I didn't devour this book in a single gulp, like I did with the first book.
The Block
The Block rated it 18 years ago
Enjoyed this more than the first one. Once you get used to the style you can't put it down. Still don't think they're quite right for young kids though... (I was scared ;-)
CheriePie's Books
CheriePie's Books rated it 19 years ago
In many ways, I liked this book even better than the first one, Northern Lights (aka The Golden Compass). I liked how they moved between 3 different worlds, and how there were many different subplots going on. There was one thing I didn't like however... WARNING! SPOILER BELOW...and that's the cli...
afterwhat
afterwhat rated it 20 years ago
I cannot for the life of me remember which of these books was which, or what happened in which. They really are mostly all one book, a la Lord of the Rings, just split up to increase sales/commercial appeal. I also, tragically, can't remember individual plot points. I remember the gist, I remembe...
willemite
willemite rated it 22 years ago
Pullman continues the tale begun in The golden Compass. It remains fascinating, moving and carries significant intellectual payload, although I expect much of that will go over the heads of younger readers. One of the best series of its generation.
Kaethe
Kaethe rated it 28 years ago
21 Jul 199711 Nov 2000

I like Will, and his very pressing day-to-day concerns, his practicality. This is where the series really engaged me, because I could relate to Will better than to Lyra.2 Oct 2016I really hate this cover. While it isn't clear what Will's ethnic heritage might be, the...
The Welsh Bookworm
The Welsh Bookworm rated it 56 years ago
Review from School Library Journal:A direct continuation of the epic fantasy begun in The Golden Compass. Will Parry must find his father, who disappeared while exploring the far North. Mysterious strangers are hounding his mother for information about him. After Will accidentally kills one of them,...
Need help?