logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code
back to top
Search tags: Books-About-Books
Load new posts () and activity
Like Reblog Comment
text 2018-09-26 07:01
More banned books!

I recently did a couple posts about banned books, but this is a topic that could sadly go on forever.

 

I decided to look up and see which books are banned or challenged that I have either read or know a lot about (because of maybe media, it was made into a movie...etc.) I will leave links to my resources. (Most will probably have more books that I don't list here.) Please note that I do not think any book should be banned, even "bad" ones, even problematic ones. Problematic books can start discussions. Trigger Warning: The last book mentioned is about the subject of rape.

 

~

 

1. Tarzan series by Edgar Rice Burroughs

 

 

 Edgar Rice Burroughs' classic series about a man living in the jungle was pulled from the shelves of a public library in the appropriately named town of Tarzana, California. Authorities thought the adventure stories unsuitable for youngsters, since there was no evidence that Tarzan and Jane had married before they started cohabiting in the treetops. 

 

My thoughts: I never read the books. I saw the movie version, but I can't imagine the books were worth banning. The reason for it being banned speaks of the times from which it was published, I suppose.

 

~

 

2. Where the Wild Things Are by Maurice Sendak

 

 

 When the book was finally published in 1963, the book was banned because adults found it problematic that Max was punished by being sent to bed without dinner, and they also bristled at the book's supernatural themes. A 1969 column in Ladies Home Journal deemed the book "psychologically damaging for 3- and 4-year-olds."

 

My thoughts: Aw, really? I love this book and also the movie. I don't think we have to worrry about a 3 or 4 year old being damaged from it. I mean, know your child before reading a book that might be too scary for them.

 

~

 

3. Harriet the Spy by Louise Fitzhugh

 

 

 Some schools blocked Louise Fitzhugh's book from shelves when it came out in the 1960s because of concerns that the 11-year-old child's penchant for peeping on her neighbors, jotting down her brutally honest observations, and being generally disagreeable could negatively influence kids by setting a bad example. Early critics argued that Harriet "didn't spy, but rather gossiped, slandered, and hurt other people without feeling sorry about her actions," Thought Co. said.

 

My thoughts: I have a blind spot for this book. I loved it as a child and it is one of the first chapter books that really got me into reading and grew my love of writing. Why shouldn't Harriet be allowed to write her true feelings? Her notebooks were stolen; they were never meant to be read. My reading this at 11/12 turned me into a spy! I kept a journal and everything. I "spied" on people, but I wasn't cruel. I just wrote what I saw. Looking back, I see that as a kid, you see and hear more than you should. Harriet should not be banned.

 

~

 

4. Charlotte's Web by E.B. White

 

 

 A parents group in Kansas decided that any book featuring two talking animals must be the work of the devil, and so had E.B. White's 1952 work barred from classrooms. The group's central complaint was that humans are the highest level of God's creation, as shown by, they said, the fact we're "the only creatures that can communicate vocally. Showing lower life forms with human abilities is sacrilegious and disrespectful to God."

 

My thoughts: *sigh* This book is harmless. It's sad, sure! It is going to give a bunch of kids their first good book cry, but I don't see how anyone could think this book should be banned. I loved this as a child, still as an adult.

 

~

 

5. The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian by Sherman Alexie

 

 

Parents have taken issue with its “excerpts on masturbation,” claiming it “encourages pornography.” According to PBS, the novel has also come under fire for “vulgarity, racism and anti-Christian content.” But Alexie himself seems unfazed about his popular book being banned, saying in 2013, “I knew it would.”

 

My thoughts: I have yet to read this book, so I can't say if the masturbation part was explicit. I've heard a lot about the book and about how important the story is. I don't think the masterbation scene is grounds to ban the book. Young people (the character is 14) are starting to learn about their bodies. We need to stop making the subject so taboo. For the most part, I think kids, especially teenagers should be able to read what they want, but parents should be aware of the content of the media they are consuming, because of course there are things that go over the line. The line is something you and your child should discuss.

 

~

 

6. Forever by Judy Blume

 

80675

 

 This book has been banned a lot, for many reasons. Here are some. Promoting "the stranglehold of humanism on life in America. It demoralizes marital sex. Language, masturbation, birth control, and disobedience to parents. Pornography and explores areas God didn't intend to explore outside of marriage. It's basically a sexual 'how-to-do' book for junior high students. It glamorizes sex and puts ideas in their heads.

 

My thoughts: I'll be honest. I do not like this book. It is a fast read, so quite easy to read. Several things in this made me feel like I was all slime covered and uncomfortable. It is really a shame; I do remember her children books with fond memories. I still believe she is a good writer. I understand why this book may have been important for the time period it was written in, but I still think the relationship in the book was toxic and should not have been anyone's reference guide to love and relationships. I STILL DON'T THINK IT SHOULD BE BANNED! However, I would say this is a "how not to" guide in my opinion.

 

~

 

7. Goosebumps by R. L. Stine

 

https://oif.ala.org/oif/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Night-of-the-Living-Dummy-cover.jpg

 

Most of the reasons given for banning or challenging these are "too scary for intended age group."

 

My thoughts: Come on! Most of us on here enjoy horror, right? These books were so important to me when I was a kid. I loved reading them. (And Fear Street) I never thought they were too scary. Some people like the feeling of being spooked, even kids. If your kid is too scared of these books...news flash, they don't have to read them until they are ready. If they insist on reading them, despite getting nightmares, fear not, they are just horror lovers in training!

 

~

 

8. Harry Potter series by J.K. Rowling

 

24548235

 

A vocal group of Christians has been resistant to Harry’s charms from the start. Members of this community, who believe the Bible to be literal truth, campaigned vigorously to keep J.K. Rowling’s best-selling novels out of classrooms and libraries. They even staged public book burnings across the country, at which children and parents were invited to cast Rowling’s books into the flames. Their reasons: Portrayal of magic is likely to attract unsuspecting children to real-world witchcraft. When Harry disobeys his cruel Muggle guardians or flouts Dumbledore’s rules to save his friends, he actively encourages child readers to engage in lying and disobedience, which are explicitly forbidden by the Bible. The morals and ethics in Rowling’s fantasy tales are at best unclear, and at worst, patently unbiblical.

 

My thoughts: I cry. Book burning? Just no. I love these books, of course. I grew up with them. I can't imagine there are people out there not allowed to go to Hogwarts. To each their own, but please don't hurt the books.

 

~

 

9. Carrie by Stephen King

 

10592

 

Another book with many reasons for being banned. Here are some: Trash (Stephen would hope you mean "good" trash, at least.) It could “harm” students, especially “younger girls.” It does not meet the standards of the community. Language, sexual descriptions and satanic killings.

 

My thoughts: It is horor. What do you expect there to be? Sunshine and daisies? I don't think King should be banned, though he does have *cough* some eyebrow raising content in his books (IT). I think, once again, parents should be aware of what their kids are reading. If you're an adult and think it should be banned for the above reasons... well, just don't read it and let others read it who might enjoy it. For the record, I enjoyed the book.

 

~

 

10. Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson

 

 

Reasons for banning: It is soft-pornography and glorifies drinking, cursing, and premarital sex, as well as teaching principles contrary to the Bible.

 

My thoughts: I am disgusted. Do they not even read books before banning/challenging them? They are calling rape soft porn?! The underage sex was rape. Teens are not angels. Some do drink and curse, but this book did not go over the line as far as drinking and cursing. It tells the stories of a girl coping with the aftermath of being raped... ugh, I can't even. It is an important book. All ages and genders should read it. It ends, giving the reader a sense of hope. Imagine if you were raped or asulted or had another hard thing you were going through and you read a book like this that ended with "I am healing. I will be okay." It is the hope that one day you will also be okay.

 

-------

 

Resourcs:

 

http://www.bannedlibrary.com/podcast/2018/3/7/speak-by-laurie-halse-anderson

http://www.bannedlibrary.com/podcast/2015/8/30/carrie

https://education.good.is/articles/harry-potter-censorship-schools

http://www.bannedlibrary.com/podcast/2014/7/6/forever

http://educationpost.org/these-11-books-were-banned-but-you-should-read-them-anyway/

http://theweek.com/articles/459795/17-americas-most-surprising-banned-books

(spoiler show)

 

Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
review 2018-09-26 05:01
Review: Dorothy Must Die
Dorothy Must Die - Danielle Paige

Let's start with, lately I have seriously had a knack for picking stories told in first person...which I hate.  This was an interesting enough story that it was pretty easy to ignore.  This book was dark, very dark and a teeny bit gruesome.

 

Amy is a teenager from Kansas.  She lives in a trailer, her dad walked out on them, her mom has turned into a junkie that blames Amy for every bad thing in her life.  Her school life is terrible, she's been bullied for years, has no friends and no means of escaping her craptastic life.  That is until a tornado hits and sweeps her away to Oz.  Yup, just like in the movie she'd seen bunches of times as a child.

 

However, she doesn't find herself in the Oz of the movie or storybook.  This Oz is desolate and decaying.  As it turns out, Dorothy, who had gotta a taste for magic, found her way back to Oz and took over.  Now she and Glinda are mining it for it's magic and killing it an it's inhabitants in the process.

 

Amy, who has her pet rat, Star as a companion meets people who (somewhat) explain to her what has been going on and eventually she falls in with the Order.  Which is led...by...the...wicked...witches?  Yeah, things have gotten so bad that the wicked have joined forces to stop Dorothy, and Amy is their weapon of choice.  She is trained by them in combat and in the use of magic before being sent to the palace in disguise.  She's meant to be a spy to gather information that will help with their plan, only Amy is never given the details of the plan or a way to relay any information she may have discovers.  She has to wing it and in doing so learns that there is more than one faction that is trying to rise up and take Dorothy out of power... and she gets herself into trouble.

 

I like Amy, but she's too full of doubt and indecision.  Which, considering her circumstances is totally understandable.  My thoughts are that she can't really trust any of the factions, and she knows that, but hasn't exactly accepted it.  While these groups may be operating under the guise of making Oz great again--and yes that is an actual phrase from the book and it made me cringe reading it--I think they all want Dorothy out of power because she's a monster who is destroying their world, but also because they want to be in power themselves.

 

Amy has a tough road ahead because her mission is to kill Dorothy, and she royally botched it in this book.  Dorothy has managed to escape and no one knows where.  Now Amy's been thrown together with a different resistance group and who knows what they will tell her in order to get her to do what they want.  All she knows is that before she can kill Dorothy, she must stop her first companions in Oz.  That means, taking the heart of the Tin Woodman, the brain of the Scarecrow, and the courage of the Lion.  And then, hopefully, Dorothy will finally die.

Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
text 2018-09-26 02:00
Reading progress update: I've read 327 out of 480 pages.
Dorothy Must Die - Danielle Paige

OMG! Dorothy. Needs. To. Die.

Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
text 2018-09-25 23:20
Reading progress update: I've read 195 out of 480 pages.
Dorothy Must Die - Danielle Paige

 

This is both nothing and everything I expected. 

Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
review 2018-09-25 15:47
Pre-Review Thoughts: The Splendour Falls
The Splendour Falls - Susanna Kearsley,Barbara Rosenblat

The Splendour Falls

by Susanna Kearsley
narrated by Barbara Rosenblat


I have been enjoying Susanna Kearsley as far as the only couple other books I've read by her, so it was probably inevitable that I'd come across a disappointment--I just hadn't expected it so early on.  The Splendour Falls dragged something awful, and the truth is, the actual story's conflict doesn't even quite surface until about 8 hours into the audio book; 8 hours out of a 12 hour audio book.

As I had had a good impression of Kearsley since the first book I'd read, I'm hoping the next one will be a bit better.  I've noted that The Splendour Falls is apparently NOT her best work, and there's a general consensus that it might even be one of her lesser novels.  The book is still beautifully written, with lovely characters whom, while abundant and sometimes hard to keep track of, sort of came alive.  Except for our main heroine, Emily... she continued to be the boring speshul snowflake and I had a hard time relating to her.

I will have a full review out soon.

 

 



 

Halloween Bingo 2018
(a genre or mode of literature and film that combines fiction and horror, death, and at times romance)

 

 

Source: anicheungbookabyss.blogspot.com/2018/09/pre-review-thoughts-splendour-falls.html
More posts
Your Dashboard view:
Need help?