Discussion: 2016-10-01 - 2016-10-31: The Hound of the Baskervilles (Illustrated) (The Sherlock Holmes Collection • Booklikes Bookish Bingo Club • BookLikes

#23 by: Murder by Death date: 8 years ago discussions stats

I'll do that now...

Done. Hopefully that should tie all our updates together under the book club page.

#24 by: Tannat date: 8 years ago discussions stats

Reply to post #23 (show post):

I see posts!

Thanks MbD!

#27 by: BrokenTune date: 8 years ago discussions stats

Reply to post #26 (show post):

I prefer The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes as a canon, but this is my favourite of the longer works. My very favourite I think is A Scandal in Bohemia. :)

#28 by: Tannat date: 8 years ago discussions stats

Reply to post #26 (show post):

I liked it but I think I liked some of the earlier works a lot more. Plus I definitely had some issues with parts of it. I haven't read the later works yet and I don't remember the earlier ones well enough to point to a favourite though (or a top 5).

#29 by: SusannaG - Confessions of a Crazy Cat Lady date: 8 years ago discussions stats

It's a fun read, and a fun re-read, though it's not my favorite Sherlock Holmes. (That would be the Adventures.)

Obsidian, it's not in my top five, either; I don't rate it nearly as high as many Holmes fans do. I think my top five ranking is:

Adventures
Study in Scarlet
Sign of Four
Memoirs
Return

Hound of the Baskervilles is probably no higher than sixth, speaking personally.