logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code
back to top
Search tags: brandon-r-brown
Load new posts () and activity
Like Reblog Comment
review 2015-08-03 20:49
Planck: Brilliance Broken
Planck: Driven by Vision, Broken by War - Brandon R. Brown

In this biography of Max Planck, Brandon Brown weaves a spellbinding tale of both genius and naivete. Each chapter starts during the war, World War Two, then flashes back to an earlier period as a way of juxtaposing both Planck's drive (from his youth and middle age) and the process of being broken during the war. While this style may initially seem strange it is very effective and after a few chapters it creates a flow of its own. The discussions of science and math are kept at a sufficient level to understand why some of the ideas were considered bizarre if not outright insane but the discussions don't get bogged down in the science or math to the point that the book becomes about Planck's science rather than his life. Those elements, his science and his life, are both highlighted and brought together to create the sum which is Planck's legacy.

I highly recommend this book for those interested in the human side of scientific discovery as well as those interested in World War Two. The writing is strong and keeps the reader interested, so I also believe this would be enjoyable for someone who simply likes reading a good biography.

Reviewed from an ARC made available by the publisher via NetGalley.

Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
review 2015-04-02 00:00
Planck: Driven by Vision, Broken by War
Planck: Driven by Vision, Broken by War - Brandon R. Brown I got a copy of this from Net Galley.

In summarizing what most of us know about Planck, Brown described my knowledge pretty accurately. I'm a physicist, so I know about his most famous scientific work. And that he had a moustache. That's about it. Most people don't even know that. But he led a fascinating life, both scientifically and historically. His legacy is problematic because he chose to stay in Germany through the Third Reich, famously pledging his allegiance to it in 1933 when so many scientists, including Einstein, were fleeing. But he also never really accepted Nazi ideas, so it's a complicated story of trying to change the system from the inside, or maybe just clinging to the idea that science is completely separate from politics, despite all the evidence to the contrary, or maybe just plain cowardice. Or some combination of the above. But mainly it's a story of a man who saw himself as German and could imagine leaving, believing that this craziness must pass, if he could only last until then.

Einstein credited Planck with being the originator of quantum mechanics, and although not every agrees with that singular characterization, certainly he was crucial to the development of that branch of physics. Planck was already established and serving as a journal editor when Einstein was writing his early papers, and Planck could credibly be said to have discovered Einstein (though surely this was inevitable). Planck was also famous for championing the career of the young Lise Meitner, who was an early nuclear physics theorist, narrowly missing out on the Nobel Prize (but she does have an element named after her). When quantum mechanics was the hot new thing, enthusiastically developed by a group of physicists in their 20s at a breakneck speed, Planck was a well-known voice calling out for caution and conservatism, the old guard questioning the difficult ideas of the new. He died in 1947 at the advanced age of 89. This is remarkable, especially considering where and when he lived: he survived WWI and the starvation associated with it, the terrible economic times of the 1920s, and the rise of the Third Reich and subsequent WWII with all of its bombings. He buried a wife and four adult children: two daughters who died after childbirth from poor nutrition and health associated with hard times, one son killed on the battlefields of WWI, and one son who was executed by Hitler's regime for his supporting role in the 1944 attempt on Hitler's life. His remaining child, shared with his second wife, got stuck behind the Iron Curtain in Berlin after the war.

The book is full of delightful stories. It is not what I would call a historical biography, though. Usually historical biographies are concerned with the timeline of the subject's life, and Brown seems to have much more concern for the relationships and ideas in Planck's life than a straight development of events in any sense of the word. The chapters begin during WWII, near the end of Planck's life, beginning with the trial of his son and ending not long after the end of the war. A very short timeline indeed. The rest of his story is told as asides, almost. Not flashbacks per se, but background. In the first few chapters, a complete outline of Planck's life appears, although hung with few details and little explanation. Then, as the chapters proceed, Brown goes back and fills in pieces of this outline, here and there, as it suits him thematically. We end up with a pretty good picture of Planck's life, but the story-telling can be a bit jarring. It is as if a very knowledge-able person sat down to tell the story of Planck and WWII, but kept getting distracted. Also, the reader should have some sort of historical scaffolding to fit these details into: some recognition of early physicists' names, the names of the principal players in the Third Reich and principle events of the wars, and some German history. The book is not long on context.

Brown, then, does not tell stories like a historian, in context and in a straight line. But he does tell stories like a scientist, with a focus on ideas and relationships. And he's quite good at explaining the necessary basic science, including relativity and quantum mechanics.

On the whole, I really enjoyed this book. But I would principally recommend it to readers who already have a working understanding of the history of this era, and wish to fit Planck's story into that era. I'm not sure that my undergraduate students would be ready for this book. Not because the science is advanced, but because the history is not fully fleshed out.
Like Reblog Comment
review 2015-03-24 19:27
Book Review: Planck: Driven by Vision, Broken by War by Brandon R. Brown
Planck: Driven by Vision, Broken by War - Brandon R. Brown

“He’d seen his colleagues, including Lise, driven from the Fatherland. He’d seen the ever-advancing thresher of new laws, first limiting, then persecuting, then gathering Jews along with other Nazi targets. He must have known of the inhuman trains, even if he didn’t know their destination.”

 

 

This book focuses not only on Max Planck’s contributions to the scientific community, but his contribution to his his county, family, friends, and fellow scientists during one of the most harrowing times of Germany’s history. Planck had jewish friends and was often mocked as being a “white jew” himself, his standing as a credible physicist taking dire blows because of his association with the jews. But through it all, he also did not give up on his fatherland.

 

The book is well written- the author including several quotes about Planck from his friends and former students. It also includes Planck’s involvement with other physicists including Albert Einstein. The author is even comical at times, comparing Planck’s “Phantom Problems” to “The Ultimate Question” in Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy.

 

Overall, Planck was an intriguing read with insightful information on the life of the physicist. I recommend this book to fans of autobiographies or anyone looking to dig just a little deeper into the life of Planck.

Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
text 2015-01-29 08:07
TBR Thursday #25
Victorian Fairy Tales - Michael Newton
The Sham - Ellen Allen
Painless - S. A. Harazin
18 Things - Jamie Ayres
Modern Rituals: The Wayward Three - J.S. Leonard
Footsteps in the Sky - Greg Keyes
Planck: Driven by Vision, Broken by War - Brandon R. Brown
First Activation: A Post Apocalyptic Thriller - D.A. & M.P. Wearmouth
The Last Bookaneer - Matthew Pearl
AsapSCIENCE: Answers to the World's Weirdest Questions, Most Persistent Rumors, and Unexplained Phenomena - Mitchell Moffit,Greg Brown

Moonlight Reader started the TBR Thursday, and I think it's a good way to a) show what new books I've got and b) confront myself with my inability to lower my TBR. In fact, since I started recording it, it has risen significantly. I get the feeling I'm doing something wrong here...

 

Tomorrow I have my last exam and that it's one week of freedom before the next (busy) semester starts again. After two months of exams and studying I'm really looking forward to this vacation!

 

Reading this week has not been so great. I've been extremely tired (see above). I did add however more new books, even though I was trying not to. Once again less than last week (it fits in one post!) and I hope that next week I won't add new books. (But I can't promise anything).

 

TBR pile currently stands at 317. (+14)

(Netgalley ARCs at 139 (+11))

 

 

More posts
Your Dashboard view:
Need help?