Association des Résidents de la Ferme Nuttall
La Volaille
Caquetis-les-Bassecour
Recoltshire
19 juillet 1960

Cher Mr Owens,

Permettez-moi de venir vous exprimer, de la part de tous nos amis résidents, la joie que nous avons éprouvée en apprenant votre décision d'être locataire de l'étable vide de Mr Nuttall.
Cette nouvelle a rempli d'allégresse toute la ferme. Certains animaux en ont même la chair de poule, et brûlent de promener leurs plumes dans votre nouvelle tanière. Les vaches sont au septième ciel. Quant aux chevaux, bien entendu, ils sont particulièrement heureux de vous voir v-hennir.
Il se peut que vous trouviez d'abord que quelques petits oiseaux ont tendance à être d'une humeur de buse et à faire les bécasse. Mais vous devez garder à l'esprit que la plupart de ces animaux, loin d'être aussi instruits que vous, sont restés bêtes comme des ânes. Bref, j'espère que vous ne serez pas chat-griné par leurs rat-yeux-riz.
N'hésitez pas à venir fouiner par ici chaque fois que vous en aurez envie, car mes épouses et moi-même sommes toujours heureux de recevoir des visites. Nous sommes fatigués de toujours percher au même endroit, et l'atmosphère commence vraiment à cocoter.
Très cordialement,
Bertrand Lecoq
(Maître Coquin)

- Un accident très regrettable, Monsieur. C'est entièrement de ma faute. Je l'ai emmené cet après-midi faire sa petite promenade, et alors, je ne sais pas comment ça s'est passé, j'ai perdu le contrôle de sa chaise roulante, elle a dévalé une pente, et elle est allée s'écraser. Elle s'est écrasé contre le poulailler.
- Mon Dieu... est-ce que... est-ce qu'il y a eu des blessures?
- Un poulet a été décapité, Monsieur?
[...]
- A propos, qu'aurons-nous à dîner?
- Du poulet, Monsieur, répondit Pyles sans se retourner.

Tandis que les autres continuaient de se débattre et de se lancer furieusement des hypothèses, la solution se révéla lentement à moi : le coupable, bien sûr, n'était autre que moi-même, le professeur Violet.
Dès que je m'en rendis compte, le jeu me parut intrinsèquement défectueux. Il me semblait absurde de pouvoir découvrir par simple élimination qu'on était soi-même l'assassin avant même de savoir où et comment on était censé avoir commis le crime. Il n'y avait sûrement aucune situation semblable dans la vie réelle.

Oh, comme ma vie aurait été différente si j'avais pénétré dans sa chambre au lieu de m'esquiver dans l'obscurité avec la rapidité muette d'un songe qui s'enfuit au réveil.

Ils y arrivèrent peu après minuit, et dormirent jusqu'à l'heure du déjeuner, où Lady Frances emprunta une voiture de Mark pour aller acheter des cigarettes au village le plus proche. Elle avait à peine parcouru quelques centaines de mètres que la voiture explosa et quitta en flammes la route pour s'écraser sur les versants rocailleux. Elle fût tuée sur le coup.
Mark fut désespéré de cette perte. La voiture était un coupé Morgan Plus 8 1962 bleu nuit, l'une des trois ou quatre existant au monde, et elle était irremplaçable.

- Oh, il y a une explication parfaitement simple, répondit celui-ci. Le meurtrier n'est ni entré ni sorti par la porte. Il y a un passage qui mène de la salle de billard à l'étage.
- De quoi diable parlez-vous, mon vieux? éclata Thomas.
- C'est pourtant vrai. Demandez à Tabitha : elle le sait. Elle le sait parce que Lawrence s'en servait pendant la guerre.
- Quelle ineptie! Thomas se tourna vers sa tante, qui avait écouté cette conversation avec des signes visibles d'amusement. "Vous avez entendu ça, tante Tabitha?
- Oh oui, oui, j'ai tout entendu.
- Et qu'en pensez-vous?
- Je pense que c'est le colonel Moutarde, dans la cuisine, avec le chandelier.

Roddy arriva avec des nouvelles plus précises.
"Je suis allé jeter un coup d’œil aux garages, dans l'idée qu'elle avait pu partir sans nous prévenir.
- Et alors?
- Alors, sa voiture est encore là, mais elle n'est plus d'aucun usage. Un énorme hêtre a été abattu par la foudre et il bloque complètement l'allée. Nous sommes tous coincés ici."
Michael se mit à rire. "Que vous imaginiez-vous?" fit-il. Lié à sa chaise, il n'était pas de la meilleure humeur. "Nous autres, les psychopathes, nous pensons à tout, voyez-vous", ajouta-t-il.

This book was way different from Divergent, but not in the good way. I was a fan of Roth's other series and I even remember enjoying Allegiant during some parts (definitely not as much as the other two books), but I just couldn't get into this one.

 

When I picked this book up I had no idea that it was controversial. I hadn't read any reviews or really looked up the book at all, I just saw that Veronica Roth had written it and thought that I would give it a try. I am not claiming to be an expert of racism, but I don't really see why this book is so controversial. Yes, there are two groups of people of different races that are at odds, but it makes sense for the people from Thuvhe to be lighter skinned because of the climate they live in. People in colder climes tend to have much lighter skin because their skin needs to be able to absorb more vitamin D due to the fact that the sun isn't as strong (please don't quote me on this, I'm just trying to remember what I learned from classes I've taken). The Shotet live in a much milder climate, so it makes sense from them to have darker skin. Am I an expert? God no, but I'm struggling to understand why this book is so controversial. 

 

Anyway, moving on from that. This book was not at all what I expected. Divergent was a faced paced thrilling story, while Carve the Mark seemed to drag on forever. The first chapter was extremely difficult to get into. So many names are thrown around. There's a lot of confusion and it felt kind of like a mess and I was so close to just stopping there because it was that unappealing. It was too much all at once, but at the same time it seemed to move at a snail's pace. While the rest of the book definitely improved from the first chapter, the pacing did not and honestly my overall confusion wasn't really cleared up.Time seemed to fly by in a matter of pages, but it didn't feel like it and it was sometimes hard to remember that however many years had passed. I think at one point during the book it was mentioned that Akos was fifteen when he started training with Cyra, but like I'm pretty sure he was older than that when it was mentioned and I didn't realize that Akos and Cyra had known each other for years now. It was really odd and confusing. 

 

The characters weren't bad, but they also didn't stand out. Cyra was alright, but I dreaded reading Akos's chapters. They were so boring and honestly I didn't really care much about Akos in the first place so I didn't really want to read about his POV. I did think that Cyra's currentgift was the most interesting part of the entire book. I definitely liked the idea behind currentgifts and the current, but I kind of wanted a little more explanation. Also I saw the romance between Akos and Cyra coming from a mile away. I wasn't really insta love, but it also didn't feel believable. When they first kissed it kind of felt like it came out of nowhere. 

 

And now for the plot. For maybe a little less than half of the book, I kept asking myself "where is the plot?" It was basically nonexistent for a large chunk of the book and this left me feeling like there was no direction to the story for awhile. Once the plot did get going though I did enjoy it, but it wasn't really original.

 

Overall, I'm really disappointed by this book. I was a fan of Roth's other series so I was expecting a lot more from this book, but it didn't deliver. I probably won't be picking up the next book, unless it gets really good reviews.

I made a point of tracking down a copy after all the controversy. Some folks were going around saying it was racist and promoted self-harm, and that it should be boycotted. Which, imho is going a little far - censorship and book banning are terrible things whether it's the right or the left calling for it, and it's important for all of us readers to be responsible and read and think for ourselves. (Informative reviews that mention potential issues are good though.) Ok, public service message over, on to the review!

While I've seen the movies, I've never read her breakout divergent series, so I didn't know what to expect. I gave this a 3/5 stars for some really interesting and well-developed ideas that... I totally didn't enjoy reading about. Yeah. It just felt dark and like a lot of work from the start. Partly that's because it's scifi with a ton of detailed worldbuilding, which pays off. But it also doesn't resolve much and goes on to at least one more book, and this one was freaking long enough. However, if you're a scifi fan, more patient or into worldbuilding than I am, or just want to see what all the fuss is about, I'd encourage you to check it out. There's some good character driven emotional resonance, complex personalities and an intricate examination of social and familial influence, trauma and fate. But is it racist?

No, quite the opposite in fact. Some readers seem to have picked up on the fact that the female protags skin colour is indicated as darker than others' and extrapolated that her entire race is black or at least nonwhite/POC. This is major spoilers, but the other race (nation?) male protag. shares her heritage and it turns out there's some kind of secret about her birth so her background is in question. Other members of her race are described in visually diverse terms including blonde. Characters and races within the book do act racist and express racist opinions about one another, but the author takes great pains to point out the complexity of stereotypes versus the actual history and how it's shared by each race. Horrible things have become a part of the female protags national behavior, but as you read on its developed that this is a result of recent power hungry dictatorial leaders, not innate in any way. Far from being an offensive racist text, I think it brings out some timely discussions on understanding the history that informs today. Some parallels to middle eastern countries in particular where much of the west fears and denigrates people and cultures without understanding the way their own countries have contributed to unrest there and how violent leaders have corrupted things more recently and dominate their own people as well as attacking others.

So, not racist. On the other charge, promoting acceptance or veneration of pain, I do think it's been blown out of proportion. But sure, trigger warning for cutters and self harmers, I guess. There's more of a message about how accepting and owning your experience and uniqueness can change a perceived weakness or victim mentality into self awareness, power, confidence, responsibility etc. The idea that suffering can be character building isn't all that controversial and I don't think it promotes pain so much as recognizes the value of overcoming challenges. Cutting and specifically scarring is a key story element and integral to the female protags culture and the title. When we first encounter it, it's explained as a kill mark, but (spoilers) we later find out its historic and home culture originally saw it as a type of mourning and ritual of remembrance. While outsiders see it as a mark of barbarism, that's a result of violent leaders warping society to their own ends and other cultures misunderstanding and judging a people who never intended such a thing. It elegantly encapsulates the nuanced examination of race, culture and power and proves a fitting title.

Racism is terrible. Discrimination based on appearance, nation or ethnicity is terrible - and often political. Glorification of pain and violence is terrible. I'd argue that that is exactly the author's point, which is why she works so hard to explore these topics. Far from being banned, more readers should engage with this work, although I have to admit it was a dense read with so much going on!

I honestly don't know how to feel about this book.  I wanted to like it, but I couldn't help but notice the vaguely racist tone to it.  And that turned me off the entire story.

 

The story revolves around Akos and Cyra, two people from different tribes.  They share a planet, but share no peace.  Akos is from the Thuvhe nation, the son of one of the three Oracles.  This places him in the equivalent of the upper middle class.  And he is white.  Normally, I could care less about race and rarely find a need to even mention it, but it is important here.  Cyra is from the Shotet nation, the sister of the tyrannical leader of their people.  And she is black.

 

Why is race important?  Because the Thuvheits are portrayed as peaceful and civilized, while the Shotet are brutal savages.  Yes, the race lines are blurred between the two main characters, but the characterization still exists.  Even the languages of the two tribes is described in privileged ways.  The Thuvhe language is described as beautiful and lyrical, while the Shotet language is called harsh with its stops and hard sounds.

 

There were moments where the brutality displayed by the Shotet ruler were essentially rape.  True, it wasn't sexual, but it involved forcible entry and theft into another's mind.  It makes sense within the book, but I don't want to give it away.

 

It was because of this brutality that Cyra's gift manifested, the trigger being pain.  When medical advice is sought, she is told that the pain she feels comes from herself, is her choice, and is her fault.  Later, she makes the comment that she deserves it.  The pain was caused by what amounts to rape, but her character feels she deserves the pain?  That idea is very reminiscent of the rape culture.

 

And lastly, the religion of the Shotet seemed to be based at least in part on the Muslim faith.  There was a lot of negativity in its portrayal and that just seemed to perpetuate stereotypes.

 

Even aside from all of that, I just couldn't connect to the characters.  The story was slow and even when it did pick up, it was too late for me.  All in all, I think I will pass on the rest of the series.

There seem's to be a lot of hate surrounding this book. But I really enjoyed it. It's definitely very similar to a lot of other dystopians and reminded me a bit of the Red Queen. I'd say, for me it needed more world building. I felt like I forgot a lot that this was taking place in space at times and in ships. But I did love the characters and the overall plot line. I want to see more of Akos and Cyra. Looking forward to seeing where the series go.