logo
Wrong email address or username
Wrong email address or username
Incorrect verification code
back to top
Search tags: runaways
Load new posts () and activity
Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
review 2017-01-13 12:31
An Aching Kind of Growing- Brittany Rowland

    This is a really engaging piece of social drama that takes us deep into the life of a marginalised and abused teenaged girl. Most of the book appears as profoundly real as any dramatic fiction I’ve been privileged to read. Sadly, I know the story is an accurate reflection on too many young lives. Natalie comes from a theoretically ‘middle-class’ home, in a middle-class street, in a normal enough town, yet her young life is for the main part anything but comfortable.

    Natalie is a bright girl who is blighted by having a physically abusive father, and an emotional detached mother. She is the constant scapegoat for every wrong, for every misfortune, for every failure in her family, while being personally deprived of all but the necessities for life. No wonder then, that she ends up on the streets and as the victim of further abuses. Thankfully the author stood clear of introducing sexual abuse as well. Perhaps that on top of everything else wouldn’t have only detracted from credibility. The main thrust of the story is that Natalie is let down by the care system as much as by those close to her. That is a woefully familiar story, as cash strapped social programmes fail in almost every corner of the world.

     The story is very well written from a technical point of view, and very well crafted as a story. This appears to be this author’s first real leap into fiction writing, from a non-fiction writing background. I hope there is far more of her penetrating fiction to come. This is the sort of book that encourages all right-minded people to be generous towards those that are struggling; especially the young, routinely down on their luck and short of consistent support. Natalies exist in every towns’ shadows, marginalised by systems that just about support the luckiest, but which seem only to make the lives of the emotionally and physically deprived comparatively and inexcusably more intolerable.

     I recommend this book to all those with less than solidly frozen hearts, as a reminder that most street kids, usually driven by desperation to petty crime, or worse, don’t volunteer for their roles; even when that sometimes appears to be the case. This is powerful writing that, as others have said, makes this book hard to put down.

AMAZON LINK

Like Reblog Comment
review 2016-07-24 20:51
The Year of the Runaways - Sunjeev Sahota

This another hardest reviews that I have ever written and just because my feeling and thoughts are all over the place. I have a hard time between giving this three or two stars.

 

The Year of the Runaways is a bleak book, it tells account of the lives of young Indian men trying to make a life for themselves in Britain, working illegally in the guise of students, contracting fake marriages to qualify for a visa, being exploited by employers without a conscience, and living in conditions that would break anyone's spirit. There’s no doubt that it’s a realistic picture of the lives of illegal Indian immigrants to Britain, and we do sympathy with the young men who are its subject.

 

I can only appreciate the way that two of the four central characters are developed. The parallel drawn between Tochi's mistreatment as a chamaar in Bihar and an immigrant in London was painful but essential to see developed. As Tochi journey to see something valuable in himself, torn between two worlds that think him worthless, a very clear spoken call to action is cried out. The fact that any nation inevitably produces Tochis of its own is appalling. As is the fact for that matter, that the world produces versions of Narinder. As a woman, she's been told time and again that her life is not her own. As she progresses to claim something for herself, I again found something so real in her struggle. Both she and Tochi are unfairly tangled up in their struggles because they were born in the wrong place at the wrong time, and the injustice of their circumstances is impossible to miss.

 

There are many characters in the book to keep track of initially and sometimes with going back and forth between present and the past, I had a hard time distinguishing them apart. There are also so many, and I mean many, times Punjabi words or phrases are in the book and usually I did not know what it meant. I hard a hard time getting into this at first but then the story picks up.

 

 

In the end, the narrative reel out of series of events that earnestly demonstrate different angels of the illegal immigrant problem. Sahota is not a bad writer, and his story is a strong one in terms of human interest. The year of the runaways is a good read.

 

My only opinion is that novel shouldn't be more than a group of moving stories, relevant to the problems of our time. I want more than that.

 

Would I recommend this novel to anyone? It depends if they want to read a realist of being in the shoes of illegal immigrant then yes, you should read it. But if you don't want to read the lives of illegal immigrant then you shouldn't read it.

 

 

This review can also be found on DW

 

 

Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
review 2016-07-13 20:03
Review: The Year of the Runaways
The Year of the Runaways - Sunjeev Sahota

Finally, I am able to read the last of the 2015 Man Booker shortlist. I make it a point to read the whole list before the prize is awarded, but American publication dates make that difficult sometimes. The Year of the Runaways, a novel about Indian refugees in England, was this year's holdout: the book that wouldn't be published in the States until months after the award.

So I read the book and, finally, I'm getting around to this review. It's been more than a month since I finished The Year of the Runaways. As I look back, I'm struggling to remember what it was I even read.

It's not that The Year of the Runaways wasn't memorable in any way. Some of the scenes and characters really stuck with me. It's just that The Year of the Runaways is such a sprawling story and those moments are sometimes few and far between. What lies between these moments is not ornate or profound, but just the simple telling of a story. There's nothing quotable here. Nothing one can point to as a defining unique characteristic of the novel. It's surprisingly uncomplicated for a Man Booker nominee. Despite this simplicity, the story is well told. It's smooth even as it makes jumps in time, place, and character. The subject is certainly poignant, but it's questionable whether The Year of the Runaways has long-term staying power. One may equate it with The King's Speech in a year that also brought cutting-edge films such as The Social Network and Black Swan, or Argoin a year with such a visually stunning feat as Life of Pi. These historical, plot-driven movies were enough for the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences to take notice, but it seems the Man Booker judges were looking for something more.

Like Reblog Comment
show activity (+)
review 2016-06-30 16:57
Although it is a difficult read, it is very informative about the plight of the illegal immigrant
The Year of the Runaways: A novel - Sunjeev Sahota

The Year of Runaways, Sunjeev Sahota, author; Sartaj Garewal, narrator

There is no work in India. Those who might offer employment blame the coming elections for the lack of jobs. The country is in turmoil. Indian families depend on their children for economic aid and support. Often, a child is responsible for the education of his younger siblings, as well. The burden is enormous. Even girls are driven to find work, in some cases in very unsuitable positions. Desperation drives them all to seek alternative ways to help their starving families. They believe their fortunes will improve in England where they have heard there is work. However, conditions there are grave for the new arrivals. Work is not plentiful, but scarce. Often they are preyed upon by those stronger and with more power. Some are illegal and subject to threats and blackmail. They frequently are forced to live in hiding and some wind up as captives. Their families back in India are not concerned with how the money is derived; they are only concerned with getting it and spending it. Often they turn a blind eye to the suffering of the child that is helping them, instead, they just accept the benefits provided, as if there was no dramatic cost to their son or daughter. In this book, few good deeds go unpunished. In this book, sometimes those least deserving prosper, while those who work harder are driven down even further by their burdens.
When these runaways arrive in England, they immediately look for work. Some employers, aware of their desperate circumstances, try to cheat them and pay them poorly, some are kind and even lend them money, still, luck seems to evade most of them and their situations do not improve. Their situations are ghastly. Some are accosted by thugs and bullies who use heavy handed tactics to blackmail them; some are robbed. Some are preyed upon by landlords who know they are illegal. Some are humiliated because of their status, their caste, and they cannot escape the shame of it.
There are some organizations and an occasional kind person who does not abuse them. Instead they provide them with food and sometimes a place to sleep and wash up. Mostly though, the characters in this novel live in squalor and face hardship. However, in some cases, even those terrible conditions are an improvement over what they had experienced at home, in India. Their hopeless condition causes them to fight among themselves and use each other without regard for anyone else’s safety. They are rude to each other, use crude language to appear braver than they are, behave cruelly and inhumanely toward friends and enemies alike. They seem to have little remorse or conscience because of their desolation and fear. Most have no social conscience and are very naïve having never been exposed to the developed world before. They are, therefore, very easy prey.
Although the story is overrun with characters, it concentrates on Randeep Sanghera, once a student, his “visa wife”, Narinder Kaur a young woman who agreed to the arrangement because she was filled with guilt because of the tragic death of a “friend’s brother”, Avtar Nijjar, Randeep’s friend who traveled with Randeep to England and who has a student visa, and Tochi (Tarlochan Kumar), his very angry and aloof roommate who is hiding the fact that he suffered a great tragedy, is of a very low caste and has no visa.
All of the characters are in desperate need, in danger of being sent back to India. All earn very little and live from hand to mouth, scrabbling every day to make money to pay off debts and fees, to have enough money to send home, and sometimes, even for themselves. They choose accommodations to live in that the board of health would shut down in any country if they knew of it and often, they skimp, even on food. Each of them has a tragic story. In their normal lives, violence is accepted, stealing is accepted, racism is accepted. Although religious, they don’t seem to be governed by a G-d that demands compassion. They simply believe in a G-d that will provide. As a result, they often rely on unreal expectations. Some have been so disillusioned that they have turned away from their religion. Some take it to the extreme.
I found the book really confusing because of the number of characters, the strangeness of the names and places, and the many phrases that were not translated into English. The story jumped around from character to character, place to place and even time frame to time frame. Its redeeming feature for me, and the reason I rated it highly, is the fact that I learned so much about the lives of those who runaway and also about their lives in India. The book presents a picture of the way those in different economic circumstances and different castes treat each other. It presented a very clear image of the violence during the time of turmoil in the book. The cruelty and coldness of those who had more advantages was shocking. The fact that those of lesser castes accepted their status readily, for the most part, was also disturbing and bewildering. The cruelty they were willing to inflict upon each other in the name of self-righteousness, religion or need, was very unjustified as far as I was concerned. Their selfishness reached new heights. The author did not paint a pretty picture. It was difficult to find a character to admire or even like.
These young people were victims of their times. Having never known abundance, they were satisfied with far less, and they were grateful for small kindnesses. Politics and penury had defeated them in their own country, and then even England revisited the same pain upon them. They were forced, in both countries, to humble themselves and beg for a job, money or mercy. Still, some refused to be defeated. In the end, I wondered if what they achieved was worth the price they paid, the suffering, the danger, the fear they were forced to endure. Was it perhaps futile, since they seemed to wind up exactly where they were before they ran away? Their world views remained the same. Yet, on the other hand, some of the characters did move on, and after some years, were able to find better jobs back home when the situation in India improved. They were able to maintain what they considered a better lifestyle than the one they had prior to their leaving. Certainly, though, they did not achieve a level anyone living in the developed world would happily accept.
Although the women in the book appeared to be of a less powerful class, they seemed to exert a great deal of influence and have a lot to say. They did seem preoccupied with anger and envy, however, in the same way as some of the men did, but their remarks seemed only biting and their behavior arrogant, while the men’s comments seemed more cutting and their behavior seemed more cruel and violent. The often unrecognizable names and expressions created a language barrier that would have been easier to deal with in a print edition, although the narrator was very good, speaking in a well modulated tone at a steady pace with appropriate stress and expression.
I found the book extremely informative. It even illustrated a moment in time when the young people who were engaging in this dangerous, illegal behavior, began to question whether or not they were aiding their families out of love or out of a sense of duty, and after awhile they even began to question their own actions. They were placing themselves in great danger and to what end?

Like Reblog Comment
review 2016-04-05 00:00
Runaways
Runaways - keerawa Runaways - keerawa A bitter sweet short fic in which teenagers Dean & Sam are taken into St. Jerome’s where a series of boys have gone missing. Told from the first person pov of Maddy Connor who works at the boys' home. No sex.
More posts
Your Dashboard view:
Need help?