by Leigh Bardugo
Book 1 of Nikolai Duology
It feels like it's been ages since I read the Grisha trilogy, and, as others might have pointed out, a reread of Bardugo's debut trilogy might have been beneficial. I remember some details, but not others, and it might have been the reliance of back story knowledge that had me feeling like this book was a bit hard to get into in the beginning. It probably also didn't help that there were a lot of POVs, even though we really just switched between three main ones--Nina, Nikolai, and Zoya.
And in truth, I feel like Bardugo handled the multiple POVs and the multiple story lines A LOT better in the Six of Crows duology (which had been known as The Dregs duology at some point, and is now going to get a third book apparently which has caused me to feel completely flustered, because that's all I can think of now, so the rest of this review is sort of a blur.) The truth is, because of the connection between these two series, it was hard NOT to make those comparisons, which might have been a bit unfair to this book. I found myself wondering if any of the other Dregs would make an appearance, and whenever Nina's POVs swung around, I wondered if she'd run into Inej or Kaz, or whether they'd suddenly pop up to help her with her missions... as awkwardly dropped as those instances would have been.
But enough of the Six of Crows versus Nikolai comparisons, because this book is quite obviously a sequel series to the Grisha trilogy. So, to start, I DO highly recommend reading that trilogy before jumping into this one. I even highly recommend reading the Six of Crows duology first as well.
Because while this book COULD stand on its own in some ways, I feel like there were too many references to previous books that could cause fleeting moments of "I wonder what that was about?"
Back to this book...
As I had already mentioned, I had found the beginning a bit slow to get into--dragged a little bit, even. And despite the fact that every tangent seems to have its significance, the book still feels like it tried to cram too much material into one book... and yet there were a lot of moments where I just wanted to get on with the story.
It's conflicting, because it's not like I didn't like this book. In fact, I very much enjoyed it, because aside from the story's outline and presentation itself, Bardugo has a way with words and creation that really just draws you right in. Bardugo's Grishaverse is a wonderfully crafted place, and I've always loved how intricate all the details of her world are presented, how you can pluck any character out of the world and there can be a whole story to tell. Even background characters have their significance and aren't just there for filler.
King of Scars is a book I've been looking forward to ever since it's announcement because it boasts two characters I came to love from previous series. While I was never in the Nikolai/Alina camp, I always found Nikolai charming and fun to follow as a side character to Alina's journey. And while I had started off Six of Crows not quite feeling Nina as a character, I slowly grew to love her as the books progressed. Finally, as mentioned already, I just love Bardugo's Grishaverse!
King of Scars ended up being enjoyable and entertaining, but maybe I was over-hyping myself, or I was just expecting so much more, but I couldn't seem to relate with any of the characters, or find myself caring a whole lot. Nikolai doesn't come off as charming as I remember, even though an inkling of that charm kind of hung in the background. Nina's story was a bit rocky to begin with, got a little bit better, but then I feel like it sort of lost direction at some point.
In contrast, I found that I DID really like Zoya and really appreciate the glimpse into her history. I honestly don't remember much about Zoya from the Grisha trilogy, except as maybe the "mean girl" Alina had to steer clear of. The focus on her as a main character made her so much more fleshed out; and maybe because I didn't have any strong feelings for or against her previously, it was easy to kind of accept her as a new character altogether. But that doesn't mean that I really felt any strong feelings for or against her in this book either. I liked her, but not in that "I've got a new favorite character" type of giddiness.
Anyway, in the end, the book DID suck me right in as all the conflicts started coming to a head. I really like the new twist to Grisha powers and hope to see it expounded on in the next book. I never really expected this book to be a romance, and just as well, the whispers of the romances were a bit lacking in chemistry, as well as in credibility--this is something else that I'm hoping will be developed a bit more if we're going to pursue this line.
Also... are we going to see any other old favorites in the next book? Inej? Kaz? Jesper? Yes, please? =P