Reply to post #128
(show post):
I'm a little confused about how editions are separated. I like to be able to go to a book and see a compilation of reviews about it either after or before I read it. It looks like they are separated by edition on here? Is it possible, for example, for one reviewer to write a review of a hardcover edition, and then two years later, write a review of the paperback, and have both reviews show up on the same book page?
I agree with this! I'd like to be able to go to a page on "
Hamlet, by William Shakespeare" and see all reviews/posts about it, instead of reviews being fragmented to Penguin, Signet, Dover Thrift, Arden, RSC, Oxford, etc etc etc editions. Basically, a page for each book (possibly with options for filtering by edition, or sub-pages for each edition, if editions are important?) rather than books being separated into various editions, some of which may not be very different at all (or just hardcover/paperback/Kindle versions of the exact same text).